WW17 - A Game of Thrones

[pindicator]

Duck in from break-
Mardoc, why do you like coco today when you didnt yesterday?
i think his absense is genuine, but i dont think it indicates scum or village either way. I just like the TT case better

Rowain-
Thanks for being constructive again, even if i'm not sure how to place this as scum/village.

TT-
Who would you vote for if you weren't voting defensively? You didnt say anything the first half of the day IIRC and then vote coco at the halfway point. Its like that was your only play today, to follow through on your ultimatum set yesterday

Lewwyn-
At a glance i'm having a tough time understanding your arguments. Sadly break is ovet

[Mardoc]

Duck in from break-
Mardoc, why do you like coco today when you didnt yesterday?
i think his absense is genuine, but i dont think it indicates scum or village either way. I just like the TT case better

I suppose it's the same sort of thing. I thought Mattimeo was more likely scum, but I'd have lynched them both if I had that option yesterday. Although the fact that Mattimeo was pushed to the lynch by Serdoa does make me think Coco is more likely a partner of his, since that push came right when Coco was in danger yesterday.

For absence - I think it's the Molach thing. Not that Coco is here all along, but that he's trying less hard to show up in thread than he would otherwise.

[zakalwe]

since that push came right when Coco was in danger yesterday

Not really accurate, as I commented earlier.

[Mardoc]

since that push came right when Coco was in danger yesterday

Not really accurate, as I commented earlier.

Just looked through the last ~60 posts, and I don't see your comment about this. Care to give me a link? And/or explain it again?

[zakalwe]

(Back on a keyboard.)

You can read all of Serdoa's posts here: http://realmsbeyond.net/forums/showthrea...#pid311121

Serdoa started his push on Mattimeo here: http://realmsbeyond.net/forums/showthrea...#pid310150

I'll moderate what I said earlier; I guess it's in the eye of the beholder. Serdoa switched off Lewwyn, who was in the lead, putting Coco in the lead. But if you look at the trends in some of the preceding posts, you might argue that Serdoa was sensing the tide turning, and decided to push a new candidate, hoping Coco's lead would be temporary. Also, the votes were still quite spread out so it's really hard to draw any strong conclusions.

Also, I just noticed this: Right before Serdoa switched OFF Lewwyn, Rowain voted FOR Lewwyn. So this doesn't look like Serdoa and Rowain are in league, at least not if one of their fellow scum was in danger at the time. (If all was clear, they could just have been shuffling their votes around.)

So yeah, Serdoa switching to Mattimeo to protect Rowain doesn't really make that much sense, considering that Rowain switched to Lewwyn at the same time. So either Serdoa was just pushing for the sake of it, to make sure someone innocent got lynched, or maybe it was indeed a move to save Coco.

Regardless, I like the case on TT better.

Cross-posting with Mardoc, there you go.

[zakalwe]

Getting distracted again, back later.

[zakalwe]

I previously talked about that in post 366: http://realmsbeyond.net/forums/showthrea...#pid311023

[Qgqqqqq]

How long to deadline?

[Twinkletoes89]

Guys,

Some stuff has come up and I'm not going to be in the right headspace to care about this game for the rest of the night and maybe tomorrow too. There are more important things right now.

Lynch me if you want, I've done the best defending I can and use that to decide, not this.

[zakalwe]

How long to deadline?

1 1/2 hours