WW17 - A Game of Thrones

[pindicator]

GG mardoc. I liked your posts this last day. Next time you play don't get so down on yourself, i think your analysis was quite good.

Agree with your prediction Qgqqqqq, but i dont think we need to rush anything. I'm optimstic that Tasunke is the final scum. He never answered questions and spent a lot of the day trying to cast doubt on people that were being cleared. Did he ever reveal a role? Or just his name?

[pindicator]

GG mardoc. I liked your posts this last day. Next time you play don't get so down on yourself, i think your analysis was quite good.

Agree with your prediction Qgqqqqq, but i dont think we need to rush anything. I'm optimstic that Tasunke is the final scum. He never answered questions and spent a lot of the day trying to cast doubt on people that were being cleared. Did he ever reveal a role? Or just his name?

[Lewwyn]

Well just so people realize, the last scum has a power role. We've seen 2 vanilla scum and 1 scum with a role and that llikely means that the last one may have some ability. Serdoa was a jailor so that might be a role blocking ability.

[Qgqqqqq]

Or a role scanning ability.

[Jkaen]

Thats quite a few roles that Mardoc had there beyond the double vote. Wonder why he didnt claim them all just before he died to give us more info?

Azza - Obviously not lying about his power. Cant understand any reason for the last scum to help clear people, so strongly innocent
Tasunke - the only player not to role claim (Azza I think makes your scan tonight obvious). all game I have felt he was a bit strange but put that down to 'normal' Tansuke. Most likely to be scum. If Lewwyn is telling the truth then should die tonight.
Lewwyn (aka Loki) - I am beginning to suspect he is lying about the details of his power, however I still feel he is probably innocent as I dont see the scum having a vig (I think he may only have killed once)
Qgqqqq - While I could see scum in this variation having a baner/doctor it seems he did protect me on night 3 against a scum kill, hnce need to assume inncoent
Jkaen - I know I am innocent
Pindicator - Seems to have gained village cred the old fashioned way (by actually playing well) but there is no real solid reason he cant be scum. If he is then he played a great game but should hopefully lose due to removal of viable other lynch options

[pindicator]

Wanted to add on to your thoughts here jkaen:

Azza - Obviously not lying about his power. Cant understand any reason for the last scum to help clear people, so strongly innocent

Well, scum only need to keep doubt on so many people, because they can night kill others. Still, I think it is very unlikely Azza is scum based on his claim. I give a small chance of him being scum, but it would be a lot of restraint for him not to kill Lewwyn if he was scum and found out his role on day 1. Also, it was Azza that said he didn't trust the day 2 push on Lewwyn - that statement makes a lot of sense if he knew that Lewwyn was a vig, and doubly makes sense with him as town.

Tasunke - the only player not to role claim (Azza I think makes your scan tonight obvious). all game I have felt he was a bit strange but put that down to 'normal' Tansuke. Most likely to be scum. If Lewwyn is telling the truth then should die tonight.

Really, Tasunke has to be it. He hasn't answered any questions posed to him this last day, instead only trying to cast doubt on others. If he isn't the last scum then you guys are going to need luck (and I say you guys because it sounds like I'm being lined up as next most likely). Still, I'm 99% sure it's Tasunke.

Although ideally we don't want Azza and Lewwyn on the same target. I don't know if they want to telegraph their intentions to each other or just guess, but best case is that Azza targets someone else in case Lewwyn's target isn't the last traitor.

Lewwyn (aka Loki) - I am beginning to suspect he is lying about the details of his power, however I still feel he is probably innocent as I dont see the scum having a vig (I think he may only have killed once)

Every time I've started having doubts about lewwyn he's gone and done something very pro-village. So I'm casting aside doubts. His claimed vig shots have made good sense. The only question I have about a kill standpoint is who killed serdoa night 2. Either thestick got to kill lurkers every day and a real player every other day, or maybe one of novice's abilities was to take out the person who night killed him? Anyway, we'll find out when this is over. Lewwyn is up there with Azza: loyalist.

Qgqqqq - While I could see scum in this variation having a baner/doctor it seems he did protect me on night 3 against a scum kill, hnce need to assume inncoent

Probably the most confirmed of all the loyals. And am I glad he didn't get back in time to protect novice night 2!

Jkaen - I know I am innocent

Well, while I can't share your knowledge, I do think you've played a game with a lot of village tells. I like how you came in to the game after being away on trip. Not so much the mattimeo vote, but how you went over the situation day 3 and got yourself reassessed.

Pindicator - Seems to have gained village cred the old fashioned way (by actually playing well) but there is no real solid reason he cant be scum. If he is then he played a great game but should hopefully lose due to removal of viable other lynch options

Thanks for the compliment! I'm trying not to get too ahead of myself, but I am very pleased with my scum hunting this game, especially after how poor a hunter I was last game. I really hope Tasunke is the last traitor; that will get me my first ever WW win

[Qgqqqqq]

I dought mardoc had other roles - just flavor text

i out lined earlier why helping village would be good for wolf azza, scroll back a bit.

[Qgqqqqq]

This will probably be my last post for the next 24 hours - i need to sleep and then have 2 3 hour exams.

Thoughts: i will be protecting myself tonight, as a baner is to powerful in the end game
last scum wont be roleblocker as serdoa was jailer
shoot tasunke
scan someone random (pin?)
good luck village, fingers crossed!

[Jkaen]

Lewwyn (aka Loki) - I am beginning to suspect he is lying about the details of his power, however I still feel he is probably innocent as I dont see the scum having a vig (I think he may only have killed once)

Every time I've started having doubts about lewwyn he's gone and done something very pro-village. So I'm casting aside doubts. His claimed vig shots have made good sense. The only question I have about a kill standpoint is who killed serdoa night 2. Either thestick got to kill lurkers every day and a real player every other day, or maybe one of novice's abilities was to take out the person who night killed him? Anyway, we'll find out when this is over. Lewwyn is up there with Azza: loyalist.

My theory is day 1 and 2 was the serial killer (note both these days a lurker died). Day 3 Lewwyn took his shot on Rowain

[Jkaen]

Oh and Qgq is currently still 3rd on my hit list.

Tansuke - Pind - Qgq.

Main reason, normally doctors cant self protect, he is claiming he can and will. If that is the case why wouldnt the role just be called baner as per standard. That would mean night 3 either they hit Rowain too, or they held off a kill for cover. I realise its not too likely, but it just doesnt sit right with me