WW 18 Siege of the Dragon! (Game Thread)

[Tasunke]

Lynch Tally

Waterbat(7) Zakalwe Bigger Qqqqq MJW Ichabod Mattimeo Rowaina
Azza (2) – Uberfish Lewwyn
Uberfish(2)- Pindicator, Novice
Mattimeo(2)-, Selrahc Slowcheetah
Ichabod(1)- Uber
Zakelroy(1)- Serdoa
Qgqqqq(1) –MJW

[Bigger]

thats all wrong tasunke. Q should have 4 votes and waterbat 6.

[MJW (ya that one)]

Mattimeo might have a chance of going down.

[Tasunke]

Mayor Tally

Serdoa(5)- Rowain, Waterbat, Uberfish, Azza, Serdoa
Novice-(5) Zakalwe MJW, Selrahc, Novice Qqqqq
Bigger (4) – Slowcheetah, Pindicator, Mattimeo, Lewwyn
Ichabod (1) – Ichabod

[MJW (ya that one)]

thats all wrong tasunke. Q should have 4 votes and waterbat 6.

Qgqqqq because the only reason I switched was because of Tasunke's bad lych tally.

[Serdoa]

Bigger, just give me the argument actually made for waterbats guilt, then I can try to white-knight him (or agree with it and vote him). Right now the best I can tell you is:

vote either Mattimeo or Qgqqqqq. Both had made cases against them (Mattimeo by zak, Qgqqqq by me) and both seem for me the better lynch target with the info we have.

[zakalwe]

Anyhow, not to happy with waterbat, but mostly because I have not seen all that much convincing about him. It feels more like taking someone who hasn't contributed too much because there is not enough time to actually think about the others.

I very much agree with this, looking back through his posts nothing looks particularly bad. Waterbat's posts look rushed, but he has explicitly stated he's both been busy and ill, so that's understandable. The only other candidate I can see would be Mattimeo at this point, as a policy lynch on lurking and only looking out for your own skin.

Yeah, this is how I feel, too, about not having time to think.

But Mattimeo would actually be a decent lynch under the circumstances, since he already had a chance to defend.

Mattimeo

[uberfish]

Qqqqqqq

[Tasunke]

please try to not vote in posts where you are quoting a whole bunch. I saw a ton of votes within quotes that I didn't see in actual posts >.>

[Tasunke]

Lynch Tally

Waterbat(6) Bigger Qqqqq MJW Ichabod Mattimeo Rowaina
Qgqqqq(3) –MJW, Qgqqqq, Uberfish
Mattimeo(3)-, Selrahc Slowcheetah, Zakalwe
Uberfish(2)- Pindicator, Novice
Azza (1) –Lewwyn
Zakelroy(1)- Serdoa