WW 19 Game Thread - Mobster Mayhem - GAME OVER

[Azza]

I think the novice situation needs to be resolved.

So Rowain.

[Ryan]

I think the novice situation needs to be resolved.

So Rowain.

I agree with
[/color] Rowain. Only guy I agree with :P

[Qgqqqqq]

And now you just did the novice with claiming you have an item...

What problem do you have with no vice?

[Lewwyn]

Anyway I disagree that we should lynch novice today.

[pindicator]

Why does this novice thing still have legs?

He said he was going to pass the item tonight -- which is very pro-town thing to do, unless I'm missing something. By passing the item he is leaving himself open to a Ouija scan.

Now, the alternative is that he's scum and this is a ruse. In that case a fellow scum must have the Fool Card (otherwise we would have heard from someone else who really does have the fool card by now), but by saying to pass it along who is he going to pass it to? If it get passed to a villager then we can scan novice truly and reveal if he is scum or village. The only safe move is that another scum holds the card and then passes it to novice after novice said he's passed it along. But novice then has to have someone to pass the card to. This requires a teammate to reveal himself to go along with the scam.

The solution is that we can keep forcing the movement of the Fool Card (or lynch the person who refuses to move it). Either the wolves keep revealing more of their members in an attempt to keep the ruse going, or they get tripped up.

I say it's better to let this novice thing play out. If he is scum then he'll trip up on his own, and if they want to play a high-risk game then we may get a whole lot of wolves caught in it together.

Well, I hope the wolves don't have the lock pick now but well, here goes. I have a good item, and I plan on passing it tonight (partially bc I have to reveal).

It's not day 1 without a Tasunke reveal!


I want to hear more from Rowain, especially in response to a lot of this novice talk that has gone on.

[Lewwyn]

We need to do something else. I think novice is likely innocent and Rowain is too. Scum is NOT going to draw so much attention to themselves on day 1! Not only that people seem to want to mislynch novice just to get rid of the card... Who cares if the card is out there? We should be focused on lynching based on what we see.

I think Zakalwe has acted suspicious today.

[pindicator]

We need to do something else. I think novice is likely innocent and Rowain is too. Scum is NOT going to draw so much attention to themselves on day 1! Not only that people seem to want to mislynch novice just to get rid of the card... Who cares if the card is out there? We should be focused on lynching based on what we see.

I think Zakalwe has acted suspicious today.

Agree with this, I haven't seen the usual village zakalwe yet. Still want to hear rowain's response before deciding on joining you

And Lewwyn for mayor

[Tasunke]

I think Novice and Rowain should hold hands and ride off into the sunset together.

[Qgqqqqq]

We need to do something else. I think novice is likely innocent and Rowain is too. Scum is NOT going to draw so much attention to themselves on day 1! Not only that people seem to want to mislynch novice just to get rid of the card... Who cares if the card is out there? We should be focused on lynching based on what we see.
...

This.

[waterbat]

@lew / pin, also seemed like something was off there with Zakalwe its thin, but have to go somewhere at the moment.

@pin: you are saying novice (and subsequent holders) would tell us who he passed it to before possibly being night killed? interesting - this might force the scum to use the jailer card depending on the timing of the reveal - but that also would be information we could use.

I'm also a little suspicious that day 1 votes on Tasunke were designed to get the early claim from him. Not that these votes were necessary, its like the sun rising