WW 19 Game Thread - Mobster Mayhem - GAME OVER

[Ryan]

I dont wanna repeat a Novice fool card with Azza.. I dunno what should be done besides thinking that selrahc is most likely lynch in my book.

[Serdoa]

Well, right now I am fine with Q, Merovech or Selrahc. All 3 have not done anything to make me lean village on them.

[waterbat]

selrahc

I'm giving credit to Ryan for this, not Serdoa - who somehow will craft doing so as anti-town.

With 25 hours to go, lots more can happen.

[Qgqqqqq]

Sorry if I sounded dictating there, I did not mean it that way.
Isn't that how we addresed Tasunkes claim?
I thought it was, I know I backed off until Azza counter-claimed.

You were saying we should give him another day to prove that he has the item he claims. That's not how we handled Tasunke's claim. Later in the game, we may not have the time for that. And there's no point anyway, for items that aren't indicative of alignment. And many of them are not, IMO.

Actually yes you have a point here (And Serdoa) I suppose I was just jumping to Gas Can=village.
(I do think it is how we handled Tasunke (until he got counter-claimed), but thats by the by).

I think Serdoa has a point Selrahc.

[Ryan]

You guys said that Selrahc does the same in every ww game? and I dont know If i am a 100% right and being a newbie and leading us to our doom hahah and .. I need to reread the azza vs tasunke ordeal to decide properly on Azza... What do guys think ? how dangerous is Azza?

[Qgqqqqq]

Well, right now I am fine with Q, Merovech or Selrahc. All 3 have not done anything to make me lean village on them.

Me too.
(Minus the Q)

[Ryan]

Sorry if I sounded dictating there, I did not mean it that way.
Isn't that how we addresed Tasunkes claim?
I thought it was, I know I backed off until Azza counter-claimed.

You were saying we should give him another day to prove that he has the item he claims. That's not how we handled Tasunke's claim. Later in the game, we may not have the time for that. And there's no point anyway, for items that aren't indicative of alignment. And many of them are not, IMO.

Actually yes you have a point here (And Serdoa) I suppose I was just jumping to Gas Can=village.
(I do think it is how we handled Tasunke (until he got counter-claimed), but thats by the by).

I think Serdoa has a point Selrahc.

But your fine with Serdoa saying that you or Selrahc are ok lynches?

[Ryan]

Xpost with Q god damn you man :P

[pindicator]

Ryan, thanks for clarifying. Personally when i see a situation where two people are stating things at odds so that we know one is lying then we need to resolve it, because usually village isnt the one lying.
I can see the logic in your assessment to wait though.

On a tangeant, i am getting village vibes from Ryan. Lots of posts, and the tone seems quite carefree.

As for Azza, i am trying to think of a pro-town use of his picklock. I just think he should not use them. I also want to hear his reasoning for using it on Tasunke in the first place -- sorry Serdoa, it isnt obvious to me. It seems risky and would add confusion to us trying to sort yhings out. Although Azza claiming now is very helpful: if someone reports a stolen item or dies eoth the picklock then we know who has it.

[Qgqqqqq]

I'd have used them on Tasunke for precisely that reason - he was under a lot of scrutiny and he clearly had some role that he was claiming.