WW 19 Game Thread - Mobster Mayhem - GAME OVER

[waterbat]

Are you saying if someone reports a stolen item ( say azza picks the can from me tonight), we should lynch azza before he has the chance to pass to scum pals? Of course if someone fakes the steal, that will come out when azza flips with lock pick in hand.

In any event, for a bit of meta, I think the gloves were given to the scum so they could get their hands on one of the power items. I don't think both MJW or azza are on the same team. Seems like overkill to do tasunke like that. I strongly favor MJW as town over azza for those reasons.

[Serdoa]

selrahc

I'm giving credit to Ryan for this, not Serdoa - who somehow will craft doing so as anti-town.

Why should I craft that as anti-town? You wrote that because you believe it would upset me and probably think it's funny to get me upset, but that is not anti-town, just not very kind. But thats the internet, so I guess I shouldn't expect kindness anyway.

[Ryan]

I dont like how Novice dissapered aswell..

[Qgqqqqq]

I think knowing where the lock picks are (or who to blame if they're somewhere else) is very useful.
Whats overpowered about a MJW/Azza team.

I don't think MJW's kill is a town read at all - if he is wolf, what better chance at a kill is he going to get?
He COULD hold on for endgame, but that risks a vig kill, safer to just shoot someone and get a town lean from many in the process.

[Qgqqqqq]

I dont like how Novice dissapered aswell..

He's probably asleep/working.

I also think an MJW/Azza team is plausible as in the process MJW is giving Azza a town lean, and eliminating any chance that we would've lynched Azza today.

[novice]

I dont like how Novice dissapered aswell..

Huh? I'm right here, and I posted like an hour ago with my current take on things.

Waterbat's story is consistent, at least, so he definitely has the gas can. He might be scum, of course, I assigned the gas can to scum earlier because it feels like a very powerful town item. Which means we want it. So I'm ok with putting waterbat off until tomorrow, he isn't at the top of my suspect list anyway. Merovech is.

Btw, you do realize that I'm 100% innocent if Serdoa is innocent, and that Serdoa is quite likely to be innocent? I'd kindly suggest that you focus your efforts on the more likely candidates for now.

[Serdoa]

In any event, for a bit of meta, I think the gloves were given to the scum so they could get their hands on one of the power items. I don't think both MJW or azza are on the same team. Seems like overkill to do tasunke like that. I strongly favor MJW as town over azza for those reasons.

With my own words: "I believe Azza is scum because I believe that the lockpick and gloves were given to scum". Do I read that right or have I missed another reason you gave why Azza is scum?

[waterbat]

selrahc

I'm giving credit to Ryan for this, not Serdoa - who somehow will craft doing so as anti-town.

Why should I craft that as anti-town? You wrote that because you believe it would upset me and probably think it's funny to get me upset, but that is not anti-town, just not very kind. But thats the internet, so I guess I shouldn't expect kindness anyway.

I was just ribbing you a little Serdoa. Obviously your case strong. Again, same as before, I'm giving you tons of respect for an excellent last game. If I came across as unkind, I apologize.

[BRickAstley]

Official Lynch Vote Count

Selrahc - 4 - Ryan, Serdoa, waterbat, Qgqqqqq
Merovech - 2 - novice, uberfish
Azza - 1 - Lewwyn
Lewwyn - 1 - pindicator
Qgqqqqq - 1 - zakalwe
waterbat - 1 - MJW

Players not voting: Azza, Mattimeo, Merovech, Selrahc

24 Hours Remaining

[waterbat]

In any event, for a bit of meta, I think the gloves were given to the scum so they could get their hands on one of the power items. I don't think both MJW or azza are on the same team. Seems like overkill to do tasunke like that. I strongly favor MJW as town over azza for those reasons.

With my own words: "I believe Azza is scum because I believe that the lockpick and gloves were given to scum". Do I read that right or have I missed another reason you gave why Azza is scum?

Pretty much that's it.
Well, that and the opportunity that tasunke presented would have been too good to pass up. What occurred fits with azza scum.

I really don't believe MJW would tommy gun the obvious lynch of the day as scum. To cover for azza? I don't know. To silence tasunke before he could defend? To get some town cred? I guess some of these are plausible.

I didn't like it at first because tasunke flipped innocent, but have changed my mind.