WW 19 Game Thread - Mobster Mayhem - GAME OVER

[novice]

1. I must point out my posts are hard to understand and have logically flaws in them even as villager...look at older games. I have the hard time uncrossing the reailty of Tasunke being a lying villager vs. what I thought were the possibilties.
2. I'm not going to switch off Selrahc unless he shows up--expect to break ties or self defense. It just does not fit with his usual self. And he is one that supports me.
3. I'll be pissied if I get lyched over Selrahc or Mero-something and they fail to show up.

Now that MJW has defended fully I can chime in with my opinion.

MJW

Been going back and forth on him, but I think serdoa's slip case on him has a decent chance of being correct. The reason I've had trouble making up my mind on this is because it MIGHT be a villager leaping to conclusions, but his attitude towards azza is all over the place.

I can see a scum day vig being plausible if the village has a lot of power.

I have to disagree. I think Merovech is more likely to be scum.

Realised now when I read uberfishs post that actually we have several people who could either see my case on MJW (uberfish, novice) or had a scum-lean on him (zak). And uberfish agrees on consolidating votes. So why not vote MJW?

I see your case but I don't really agree with it. I wanted to let you push MJW though.

Ultimately though I think his play makes sense, and my impression is that the slip you're referring to was just MJW being a bit lazy about expanding on why he and Azza are unlikely to both be wolves.

To throw in a MJW-esque comment: Selrahc might have ragequit due to the imbalance of the game...

[Qgqqqqq]

Ryan: your not getting me lynched today, and I'm not getting you lynched.
We're distracting the issue at hand, and being generally unhelpful by focusing on each other.
I will rspond to your points tonight, but for now lets ignore each other and focus on the rest.
OKay?

The same move after every vote you made versus me. I am sorry I am not believing you. and here werent you using the fact that I voted Tasunke since I couldnt vote my target yesterday versus me? your being a hyporcrit on so many levels.

Your not getting me lynched today, and nor am I getting you lynched.
Why does it make sense (as town) to distract the issue like this.
ANd ease up man, its only a game

[novice]

Ryan and Q, stop crossposting walls of text that nobody reads, and vote for one of the relevant lynch candidates. Oh, I guess Q already is.

[novice]

Damn i hate tgis phone.
Selrahc, for lurking during this whole kerfluffle and not adding anything when he's been top vote.

And why would scum do that?

[MJW (ya that one)]

Hmmm... under the new rules we should give useless items to scummish players to prevent them from picking up villager items when they are randomly passed. I just noticed that.

[Ryan]

Read my posts there are four times you voted me. FOUR. There a difference between providng a shred of proof and stating wild claims with no basis except me being a new player stealing peoples words and ideas. and That one attempt I am sorry is a lie and I can quote all the attempts you voted me for lynch and raised me like that. I am not smearing you . Everything I stated is quoted. I am afraid. and yes your basing your arguments on claims, Most of your votes and arguments are based 100% on other people. I dont think you made a single argument that wasnt based of someone elses or wasnt about me. If you cant take a piss to read my posts to make sure about what I am saying that dont make claims that label you as a lier. Also, I am tired of the old wereworlk games. I did not read any of them, I only read 40 pages of the last werewolf. I have zero experience with fourms, This game on a fourm, and how touse fourms + disvussions. All I am looking at is bias to older players. You guys use older games as proof. Your are removing my arguments as copied by the more *Veteran players*. My posts are just not as worthy to be read and I have to quote it several times to be seen. Please next WW game write requirements : 1- Must have fourm experience, 2- Not allowed to state claims if new since it will be treated as false information or not important, 3- Must post in quality of players playing this game since it started on RB.

[Ryan]

@novice so that after I spent the entire day trying to lynch one of those targets , I get told the next that I listened to you and follwing your arguments for the quotes . No I am not doing that.

[Serdoa]

You make me reconsider novice. I still don't like it though, but that is certainly partly because I don't like him shooting in the first place (but I am alone with that opinion anyhow). Ok, so whom else do we have:

- Merovech
- Selrahc
- waterbat

Yeah, right. With the rule change, suddenly waterbat makes a lynch target again. Ah, well, we wait till tomorrow, just wanted no one to forget you

Ok, I'll go with Merovech novice. I had him considered earlier anyhow and called him out on a post, so he seems the next best candidate and I agree that Selrahcs being completely quiet makes no sense as scum. Though I certainly would lynch him or vig him in the next 2 day/night-circles if he does not start to contribute. You don't want to go into the endgame with a player you have no read at all on because he just posts meta and nothing else.

Merovech

[novice]

You guys are extremely unfriendly to new people. I have 0 experience in fourm discussions, using fourm posts, playing a game like this on a fourm and yet I keep getting shown that I am a new guy my posts must be wrong , etc... My posts will never be on the level on people who have been playing this game since ww1. I will never be on the level with someone who has experience with fourms and how to use the different formating , Responding and quoting. Its really frustrating when I see comparsions like this made and an excuse to call me a bad player. If you guys are unaccepting of people at my level of being begineers in games like this . Please just state this and dont accept new players.

It's a steep learning curve, and while we're generally friendly, the game thread never is. You're double a newcomer, being new to both the game and the forum. That makes the curve even steeper. I dunno, maybe we should encourage newcomers to play along in the lurker thread for their first game.

[MJW (ya that one)]

Okay then...I just spam the 'refresh button' until Selrahc shows up or until the end of the lych.