UPDATED - AITP 3 Lurker Thread - Living Players stay out!

[novice]

Should have noticed that Zakalwe wasn't saving himself by voting for Ryan.

Yeah...

[zakalwe]

Yeah... That Ryan vote by Bigger half an hour before the deadline was really terrible timing. I was willing to eat the lynch if it came to that but even then I didn't want to put Ryan in the lead so close to the deadline.

[Bigger]

Yeah... That Ryan vote by Bigger half an hour before the deadline was really terrible timing. I was willing to eat the lynch if it came to that but even then I didn't want to put Ryan in the lead so close to the deadline.

yeah, we're lucky commodore didn't catch that. really I didn't realize the deadline had changed, I wouldnt have made that vote if I had realized it.

I was also nervous about Ryan being king, because he was likely to get some real votes if he wasn't. Tasunke and Q were smart to vote for him, I think.


Q, I wouldnt mind another round.

[Qgqqqqq]

Yeah I think some of the Ryan votes were reactions to the king not getting ANY heat game 1
We should sort out a tie rule though.

[Bigger]

Yeah I think some of the Ryan votes were reactions to the king not getting ANY heat game 1
We should sort out a tie rule though.

yeah I thought of that too, but not until after the game started and it was too late.

I think king -- > assassin ---> guard is the best. guard always gets lynched first, but assassin is lynched in case of tie with king. if 2 guards are up, its random.org.

[BRickAstley]

That's why I moved the vote to Commodore. I saw the Ryan train building, very confused why, and saw that Zak would either have to vote Ryan and have us lose, or not vote Ryan and be obvious that he didn't try to save himself. Commodore had the most votes and was the target of easiest opportunity.

[slowcheetah]

Yeah I think some of the Ryan votes were reactions to the king not getting ANY heat game 1
We should sort out a tie rule though.

yeah I thought of that too, but not until after the game started and it was too late.

I think king -- > assassin ---> guard is the best. guard always gets lynched first, but assassin is lynched in case of tie with king. if 2 guards are up, its random.org.

But if you do that order and the King and Assassin are both up, then the assassin gets lynched. But before they do they get the chance to fire their shot. If they know that the only way they'd get lynched is if the king was up against them...

Obviously extremely hypothetical, because what sort of Guards try to kill their king in this game :P

[Bigger]

Yeah I think some of the Ryan votes were reactions to the king not getting ANY heat game 1
We should sort out a tie rule though.

yeah I thought of that too, but not until after the game started and it was too late.

I think king -- > assassin ---> guard is the best. guard always gets lynched first, but assassin is lynched in case of tie with king. if 2 guards are up, its random.org.

But if you do that order and the King and Assassin are both up, then the assassin gets lynched. But before they do they get the chance to fire their shot. If they know that the only way they'd get lynched is if the king was up against them...

Obviously extremely hypothetical, because what sort of Guards try to kill their king in this game :P

eh, thats a good point. maybe just king --->> everyone else. i dunno. or maybe having the king being lynched ina tie as a possibility will put some pressure on the village that the assassin needs, I dont know.

[Rowain]

IMO if the king ends up tied with anybody then all the guards are traitors and should be handled accordingly.

[Ryan]

Ya I should have killed all of you bastards and got new guards -.-