WW22 - Diaries of the Madmen

[Qgqqqqq]

Well that's good, glad peoples judgement is still better then my own...

[Lewwyn]

As for the votes on me, Ryan saying you will put pressure on me doesn't help if you don't explain why, and lewwyn stop twisting facts to fit theory you need to step back and re-evaluate because you seem to have major confirmation bias ATM.

Explain A) what my theory is and B) what facts I'm twisting.

[Jkaen]

A. I am scum
B. the timing of my vote (ie just after azza made his case) being suspicious because it was the 5th vote, ignoring it was rather minutes after somebody voiced the main case against him, which surely is more relevant

[Lewwyn]

A. I am scum
B. the timing of my vote (ie just after azza made his case) being suspicious because it was the 5th vote, ignoring it was rather minutes after somebody voiced the main case against him, which surely is more relevant

Anyone I suspect of being scum suddenly becomes a "theory"? Yeah that's not obsfucating at all.

And my stating that you voted 5th is a statement of fact from which there can be only two conclusions either you are scum and bussing or you are innocent and voting for Matt because someone made a good point. I fail to see how I'm "twisting facts". Are you denying the possibility that scum might have bussed another scum when said scum is faced with a strong argument? Because it is obvious that Matt was bussed. And I actually think minutes after someone makes a good point is a perfect time to bus a fellow scum. At that point there were already 4 votes on Matt. Then this "good point" "spurs" you to vote for him. That's pretty classic scum methodology.

Seems like you're pretty worried if this is the best you can come up with.

[Jkaen]

Best I can come up with what lewwyn? You are throwing forth half arsed cases and when I respond to the, you shift the point. I think right now anything I saw or do you will claim is scummy

[zakalwe]

Nice. Thanks for playing, Mattimeo.

Lewwyn - why would I not want to be mayor? And why didn't you break the mayor tie?

Q - what is your current stance on Novice?

I also suspect Jkaen, mainly because Mattimeo didn't switch to him. And I don't just mean near the deadline, when not switching could be an easy way to frame him, but also earlier in the day. His case against Novice didn't make much sense, yet he stuck with that vote even after I pointed it out. He was given every opportunity to backpedal softly into a "hmmm, well I guess maybe we're both innocent, after all" stance and vote for Jkaen to save his skin. But he didn't take it.

I will reread and see if anything else sticks out, though.

[Qgqqqqq]

Probably innocent really.
His play felt super scummy, but I don't see that as how a wolf-wolf mason pair would play it at all, so I'm going with strong innocent, to the point of being a probable night kill.

[zakalwe]

Ah, the mayor tie was made by the puppeteer. Still, you could have put your mayor vote where it counted, Lewwyn.

On a related note, forcing Azza to not vote is anti-town.

[zakalwe]

Probably innocent really.
His play felt super scummy, but I don't see that as how a wolf-wolf mason pair would play it at all, so I'm going with strong innocent, to the point of being a probable night kill.

Ok. That's the "correct" answer, for what it's worth. I wanted to see if you had changed your mind about "fancy play" theories.

[Qgqqqqq]

Yeah...problem is that its also the only reasonable answer that can be given (apart from catwalk/mjw/tasunke ) - so basically my answer is:
I may not be going along with the group consensus but I'm not crazy

Not really relevant, but I'm in a odd mood at the moment.


Interesting point on jkaen, though IIRC we've had a similar situation with matt where he didn't do anything as scum...