WW22 - Diaries of the Madmen

[Qgqqqqq]

Its good to have such...detailed argumentts to face :rolleyes:

[Gazglum]

I followed Lewwyn as I felt he was trying to set me up as a mislynch. Also I didnt expect him to be nightkilled over Novice and/or Zak but after that he was probably the main person who could do a lot of damage as scum by getting people behind his ideas

It's an unfortunate coincidence that you followed the one player whose night action was then confirmed by Novice, isn't it Jkaen? And who then died. Bad luck really.

Also, given that your tracker result could now give us no new information, what was the motivation for revealing it after Novice at all? How did it help the town?

[novice]

Not keen on Azza as scum partly because it was his argument that moved me onto Mattimeo, I dont see the need for that if he was on the same team

Azza was only parroting my case really, although it did seem half the village didn't understand my case. It might not have been clear to scum at the time though that every villager had "village" in his role PM, so village credit to Azza for stating that outright.

Zak, Uber, what are your takes on this?

[Qgqqqqq]

There's a strong push for his lynch, so telling it gives full disclosure.
I'm inclined to believe him tbh.

[Jkaen]

I followed Lewwyn as I felt he was trying to set me up as a mislynch. Also I didnt expect him to be nightkilled over Novice and/or Zak but after that he was probably the main person who could do a lot of damage as scum by getting people behind his ideas

It's an unfortunate coincidence that you followed the one player whose night action was then confirmed by Novice, isn't it Jkaen? And who then died. Bad luck really.

Also, given that your tracker result could now give us no new information, what was the motivation for revealing it after Novice at all? How did it help the town?

Because its quite clear I am going to be on the block today, hence it makes no sense to hold anything back even for say half the game day

[zakalwe]

Not keen on Azza as scum partly because it was his argument that moved me onto Mattimeo, I dont see the need for that if he was on the same team

Azza was only parroting my case really, although it did seem half the village didn't understand my case. It might not have been clear to scum at the time though that every villager had "village" in his role PM, so village credit to Azza for stating that outright.

Zak, Uber, what are your takes on this?

He didn't say everybody had village in their PMs. (How would he know?) He said that his PM said village, and that thestick consistently used village in their communication. The first was a safe claim to make, and the second could very well be true either way. So I don't think he gets any village credit for that.

Maybe half a town point for not immediately busing his partner, though. After all, he loves to do that.

[Azza]

Its good to have such...detailed argumentts to face :rolleyes:

It's mostly gut feeling. I suspect you as being the puppetmaster, who is almost certainly scum.

[novice]

Yeah I don't know why you find that train of events so damning...

He straight out accused me of lying about my role PM.

So would I if something didn't match...so did you.

...wrong: He said town instead of village, and he said a instead of the. The reason I got suspicious in the first place was that it said "The" in my role PM, which indicates I'm the

[Horrible quoting I know...]
*Sigh*
Yeah this argument is stupid. meta based, and pulls at tiny strands expecting a web.
I plan on ignoring this novice, as I think its a distraction to the village.

So you thought one of us was lying, but you wanted to ignore it?

Your actions at the end of day 1 really are ridiculously suspicious, like Azza said.

Qgqqqq

[Qgqqqqq]

I didn't think we could learn anything from it, and I thought (and think) that meta based arguments about wordplay when the gamemaster states there is no theme are stupid and not something I'll play by.
Seriously, we spent a while puzzling over how the gamemaster would create roles (copy and paste or no?) and I will never be liking those arguments.
Sure it worked this time, but that doesn't mean we should do it.

So would I too =/= I thought one of you are lying

Oh great your looking for roles now :roleseye:
Lets look at this methodicaly, ignoring my scumminess or lack thereof.
Why do you think I am the puppdtmaster?
[I presume] Its because I am confronting the meta assumptions people have on it, and insinuating the possibility that they could be town rather then scum.
Therefore [I preume] you are thus assuming that I am the puppetmaster. But why, as puppetmaster, would I be doing these things? Why as pm would I be wanting these ideas to be brought forward, especially considering I cannot claim puppetmaster, nor survive a day after being caught as pm as I have already claimed miller.
With the knowledge that such a claim would be my doom, I would be lying low on the topic, so as to countermand roleseers.
Also, why would I as pm (without a doubt the most powerful scum role, if what we've seen so far is any indication) claim miller, thus increasing my risk of scrutiny? Why should scam play risky with their best powerrole?

If you are presuming it because the votes match my opinions then ROFL is all I can say.

[Jkaen]

Qg,

With the miller claim behind you what scrutiny is it you would fear if you were infact the PM?