WW22 - Diaries of the Madmen

[zakalwe]

Did you edit that post?

[uberfish]

Another WTF. Why can't it be 2.5 wolves? Isn't that what you theorized, earlier? Have you decided to get on Ryan's good side now?

Because if ryan is scum puppetmaster then wolves still have to have a roleblocker. Wolf team being Ryan with 2 powerful abilities + Matt with just neighbour makes no sense.

Ok, I suppose it could just be a reaaaaalllly imbalanced game. In which case I don't care and just blame thestick for the loss. Gazglum's martyr role descrption was WTF.

[Ryan]

Sigh , and you just called me an idiot. Time to go off not in the mood to play after that.

[MJW (ya that one)]

Did you edit that post?

Nope, under the new system when you edit a post the fact you edited it always shows up--even if you edit it at once after posting.

[zakalwe]

Ok. Maybe I was looking at a partially loaded page, then.

Sorry for calling you an idiot, Ryan. You did ask for criticism earlier, and lying to the town is idiotic. I don't think you're a bad person.

[zakalwe]

I'll put my vote on Jkaen. I don't think he's a real tracker. I think he's something else, and his buddy is a role blocker. If his buddy is caught, Jkaen will look clear, since he "must" have been blocked by scum.

[zakalwe]

I don't have time to make a more detailed case right now, but it really makes sense.

[Ryan]

Wild accusations again Zak. Why don't you just reveal your role ? You've been dodging it pretty hard. I am not taking my vote of you.

[Qgqqqqq]

Hmm thinking about it meta wise, if Ryan is scum then I agree 3.5 is too much.
However, by your own ommision zak we know we have a roleblocker, so 2.5 isn't possible.

Personal list: Ryan feels confirmed meta wise (we can winge later if not )
Uberfish feels vaguely scummy, but less so then the rest, and I like/agree with most of what he's said in thread
Zak I to back and forth on...no clue, but inclined to scum based on gut (which, admittedly, has sucked this game)
Jkaen I don't know. I'm gonna hate it if your scum after defending you all game...idk I sue me (as I'm sure lewwyn has been doing non stop in the lurker thread...) but I like him.


What's most likely scum pair for me?
Zak-uber, and forget about the roles...followed closely by zak-jkaen for a more meta based version (roles fit with scum).
Common factor?
zakalwe.
I disagree with Ryan though,

[Qgqqqqq]

I think you've played well.

Fake edit WTF is up with the forum, I missed half a dozen posts, and then it Wong let me type any more after previewing???