WW22 - Diaries of the Madmen

[Qgqqqqq]

Jkaen should keep quiet about who he tracks, so that the scum don't know.

[Ryan]

Jkean track Uber.

Just right now , it's either Q or uber lying about thier roles. I don't think Q is the garanteed lynch yet. He did the same move when we were both scum. It's going to be basically who do you think lied about thier roles. Miller or commuter. I don't like the commuter idea to be honest. Miller makes sense as to screw with town or scum and make them think we have a seer. If tas said anything about the two of them before he died since he was our ability seer. He might have wrote something in his cryptic language or he is trolling us.

It's a tough question Jkean and the only reason I doubt uber is he's good enough to do it.

[Qgqqqqq]

Hang on, you think I'm better then uber

[Jkaen]

I also think it will be uber who kills him.

Lets look at various factors:

Claim order - Q 1st, Me 4th, Uber 11th. Obviously its far easier for scum to make up a role once everything else has been claimed and there is no risk of a duplicate

Claim power - Q miller is a small negative, my tracker is a standard role for these games. Uber has a commuter power, which I assume (not been stated) is 2 shot. This seems far too strong for a 11 man game, 1 shot I would have thought would be the limit

Power hinting - Q claimed first post. I made a hint at tracker when talking about how to determien Q's alignment. Uber should have been hinting like crazy at a big power role in order to get targetted at night, and I didn't see any of that

Power usage - Q is passive. I tracked Lewwyn a strong player going after me, zak a player under suspicion and generally hard to lynch, and uber another good player who hadnt claimed at that point. Uber uses his power on night 2 and 3, seems if you have such a huge power you gamble on holding it longer so it can really shine around now when there are less targets.

Night kills
N1 - Lewwyn - a powerful player, and a chance to set up me for a mislynch
N2 - Tansuke - Now this puzzled everybody, but checking his power, he was the village role seer, so the question is did he visit somebody N1 and let that info slip?
His first post day 2 "why would scum have a jailer? "
Second post day 2 "As in I thought jailer was typically a village power. "
His last post addressed to uber "oh my fucking god. Just lock the fucking keys why don't you. "
N3 - Novice - Strong player confirmed villager, after zak.

So seems I was wrong, the scum don't have a roleblocker, they have a jailer, and it is uber.

[Ryan]

Wow @tas : LOL. I didn't think of those posts in that perspective. That rly dugs über a grave. That made me laugh out loud when I read it. Looks like Tas might have won us the game

@Q I said that uber is good enough to trick us.

[Ryan]

We couldn't have done this without our beloved ex mayor gazglum. I propose a toast in his name and to check your reasoning Jkean.

[Jkaen]

Lets see if uber wants to bother trying to counter that, I think its even more sewn up than I thought it was going to be when I started trying to pull the case together. I think if I was him I would wave the white flag and concede this.

[Jkaen]

I was going to carry on further with the review, don't know if its needed now, but as I am on:

Voting -
D1 - first vote on mattimeo, and gets stuck there as its obvious he is going down
D2 - Wasted vote on Gazglum, keeping off the 2 villagers on the block
D3 - Overwhelming vote on Gaz, cant analyse anything
D4 - Forced to stay on zak as we managed to persuade Q he had to vote with Ryan, hence didnt have the opportunity to jump across (note at this point due to claiming what I thought was too strong a power I was pretty certain uber was the last wolf but didnt want to muddy the waters of yesterday mentioning it)

[Jkaen]

Dead villagers thoughts

Lewwyn (N1) went down suspecting Tansuke, Q and me
Azza (D2) went down suspecting me
Tansuke (N2) we covered with the jailor comments
Gazglum (D3) went down suspecting uber
Novice (N3) went down split between Q and uber

Guess that review doesnt give us anything new

[Jkaen]

Well the lurker thread is about 10 times more active than this thread now, hopefully thats a good thing!