Posts: 4,471
Threads: 65
Joined: Feb 2006
(April 19th, 2013, 15:35)Qgqqqqq Wrote: As to the idea that "there are too many screw the players roles" - how exactly are ability scanners(!) screw the player roles??
There's 2 scanners? it's not normal to have duplicated roles and if zak had been lynched first tasunke's claim would have been questionable. The point is these roles that are already confirmed are already confusing and I don't believe there would also be a miller with no seer.
Quote:As to day 1 - if I was as you state, strongly defending a scumbudy, why on earth would I attack novice, who no one else was going to join me on - why not jkaen who had votes and broad suspicion?
Because attacking Novice discredits his arguments against Mattimeo (and meanwhile you ignored all the other scum tells that had been posted by others against Mattimeo, and dismiss the Mattimeo case as "meta" based entirely on novice's wording.) You aren't new here and you know how RB meta works especially on day 1. People just love to flip their votes around at the end of day and they don't need an explicit push to do it.
Quote:As to day 4, I was most suspicious of zak, then you, then jkaen. I considered zak a common factor until the two attacked one another enough to convince me they couldn't function as a pair. In this situation IT MAKES SENSE for me to hedge my bets and lunch the common factor.
Just because they attacked each other day 4? I don't see what happened on day 4 in particular that would have changed your assessment of zak-jkaen scum as possible to impossible.. and supposing that I was scum, zak would still have to be lynched the next day.
No, the real reason for the change of heart is that you thought you needed the last mislynch yesterday. Ryan was against you yesterday and you couldn't have known that Jkaen would tinfoil-hat me overnight.
Quote:Fake edit: OMG that's terrible Ryan.
unvote.
This is not going to chance. If your going to be a stupid villager, id rather lose then have this chosen by chance.
Yeah I actually agree with this sentiment and would rather Ryan choose. Not that your unvote really does anything to chance the situation though, as he's mayor anyway...