Really? We're going with random late-day wagons now?
Any particular reason you went with uberfish over Gaspar, of the options put forward by zak, PB? Or even why you went along with the scheme in the first place?
Now that Ryan has shown up, his 'contribution' hardly dignifies the word. I'm good with staying on him.
-- Don’t forget.
Always, somewhere,
someone is fighting for you.
-- As long as you remember her,
you are not alone.
(April 27th, 2013, 13:37)Mattimeo Wrote: Any particular reason you went with uberfish over Gaspar, of the options put forward by zak, PB? Or even why you went along with the scheme in the first place?
Hey Mattimeo.
Why not Gaspar? I like the general tone and amount he's posting at the moment. I'm content that if he is scum and keeps posting this much, he'll get caught at some point.
Uberfish on the other hand does mostly seem to be keeping himself to small posts, skipping his vote around, quick to jump on Ryan, and his response to receiving a couple of votes so far has been?
A little mild outrage?
(April 27th, 2013, 06:56)Serdoa Wrote: But looking at your performances when you were a villager, I would assume the former not the latter.
This means that you think his past performances as a villager were strong, right?
If you think back to the last game I beg to differ. He played well towards the end, by sticking to his guns and nailing me, but if you look at his day 1 play it was mystifying. He had a double vote then and was still content to let others decide the lynch. And here he says that he doesn't feel like voting, which is very much in line with that. On the flip side, why would scum spend his first and so far only post virtually begging to be lynched?
So while it does make sense to policy lynch him for not contributing, I have a hard time seeing him as likely scum. It's a bold gambit if he is.
Yeah well, at some point we need to draw a line and actually policy lynch people for pulling this sort of anti-town nonsense on day 1. I can't be sure Ryan is scum, but I'll take what I think is a better than average chance since he made one post and it was a bad one. To be honest, I was hoping being the lead wagon would draw Ryan out of the woodwork and was planning to flip back to Gaspar if Ryan posted something satisfactory and nothing else changed.
As for the wagon against me, I don't see anything to defend as the only explanation posted (by PB) is a description of my posts with no reason as to why they would be scummy or how I am deviating from my normal village day 1 (Hint: I'm not.)
Gaspar complaining about the game being dull is funny. Personally I'm happy I don't have to wade through 30 pages of day 1 in which 80% of the posts are useless noise.
