WW25 - Game Thread

[zakalwe]

I ask because I'm starting to wonder if there's just one [scum faction], what with Serdoa's meta warnings

What made you think this, Pindicator? And were you counting Azza as part of that scum faction, or as a neutral party?

What do you (and anyone else) make of the victory condition clarification by Serdoa that I pointed out earlier?

[Ichabod]

I did some rereading. Cinderella, Snowwhite, the like. The kids have heard it a thousand times before but they still insist.

Original german style ( - how can you read something like that to your kids, Serdoa and Rowain?) or the watered down modern versions?

[pindicator]

I ask because I'm starting to wonder if there's just one [scum faction], what with Serdoa's meta warnings

What made you think this, Pindicator? And were you counting Azza as part of that scum faction, or as a neutral party?

What do you (and anyone else) make of the victory condition clarification by Serdoa that I pointed out earlier?

First of all, you bringing that up when i was starting to wonder about there being one scum team was a reason why i am giving you a town lean. Similar thinking makes me think we're coming from the same place.

Reading his quote, i think it is vague enough to apply to multiple scum teams. But i think that it doesn't read like it was carefully written around that possibility. Ot's probably best to see what happens tonight but right now i'm leaning towards one scum team

[zakalwe]

You're right that we'll know more tomorrow, and it's kind of a silly thing to speculate about. So I don't mean to harp on about it, but it just strikes me that there were two cases that eventually drowned out the others today. One was my case against Slowcheetah, which was predicated on multiple scum factions, and the other was the case against me, which seemed to revolve around the same premise. At least in the sense that people were acknowledging that Slowcheetah could be scum, but maintaining that I could still be scum from a different faction. So in the end, almost everybody was directly or indirectly basing their votes on the assumption that there were multiple scum factions. Given that there's just a single kill that nobody claims responsibility for, that's (in hindsight) a somewhat peculiar consensus to emerge.

[uberfish]

Well, it's natural to assume there is a 2nd scum faction after Azza flipped in a different colour to both wolves and village. If he was a serial killer he'd most likely have protection.

Agree with novice that the secret vote has been used in a scummy fashion. So maybe it's 2-3-12, with the 2 having the secret vote? 3-3-11 feels like too many scum anyway.

[Lewwyn]

Lewwyn why did you claim that he'd played Mafia before?

Lewwyn, did you ever answer this question?

I seem to recall he did, and it concerned the "oh, Werewolf is Mafia?" reaction from Jowy, but I can't find the quote.

Yes I answered directly after he asked... What's the point to this novice?

[Gazglum]

I guess I've joined the sheep flock...sorry Slowcheetah.

I'm not sure Gazglum is cool enough to post with the poise that he does as scum.

Slander! I could be so wolfy even Serdoa wouldn't know about it.

In all seriousness, I don't remember you bringing this argument out in any of our previous games, where you've occasionally dropped a vote or two on me. I recall something about gently hushing Brick as I shoved the knife in? Am I that much more poised this time?

Uber, I think your argument that a village Zak would have shown the immediately is rubbish. It's always a better idea to hold back that kind of evidence until late in the day to try and catch scum out.

I use the word 'evidence' very loosely of course, given the result.

[Lewwyn]

welp im so dead tonight

This is so scummy. If anyone was going to die tonight it's me or Matt.

But I do have a plan. I assume that we have a protective role. I think that Matt should be protected tonight. Matt can then watch me and if I'm killed can point the finger.

Obviously the protector and Matt do not have to listen to me, but I think it's a good plan. The only problem is the scum will know in advance and try to kill someone else.

[BRickAstley]

welp im so dead tonight

This is so scummy. If anyone was going to die tonight it's me or Matt.

But I do have a plan. I assume that we have a protective role. I think that Matt should be protected tonight. Matt can then watch me and if I'm killed can point the finger.

Obviously the protector and Matt do not have to listen to me, but I think it's a good plan. The only problem is the scum will know in advance and try to kill someone else.

[Mattimeo]

But I do have a plan. I assume that we have a protective role. I think that Matt should be protected tonight. Matt can then watch me and if I'm killed can point the finger.

Obviously the protector and Matt do not have to listen to me, but I think it's a good plan. The only problem is the scum will know in advance and try to kill someone else.

Yeah, that's basically been the default plan since shortly after "Well, shit :/"

Only question is, how much to WIFOM it? :D