WW26: The Masquerade [Game Thread]

[Kate The Waif]

Uh, I meant Scarlet John

No, sorry, I meant Scarlet John

Vote stays on Muriel

[Lady Elizabeth]

I'm finally back , before I do anything I have to vote:

Scarlet John

Obviously, I know I'm a villager. The fact that he claimed watcher after the fact is not enough to make me suicide. If he is a wolf he would claim a power-role otherwise he would have almost no chance of living. Add to that the he felt that he had a good chance of getting lynch earlier and I feel that there's a good chance of him being a wolf. Him feeling in danger of being lynched makes no sense if he was a power role. Because he could easily avoid being lynched just by claiming it. So I feel he made up being a power-role after being dueled. Another big thing is that he read my post earlier and did not respond. How do I know this well he said:

"And she asked whether I was a PR at the start of the day, in hindsight I guess that was a setup for the use of this power to avoid potentially dueling a PR. Well, she just did."

The fact that he used "in hindsight" shows that he read my post earlier and did not response for some reason. This does not make sense if he is a villager, because that means he is reading the thread a lot without posting. Very strange behavior. If he is a wolf that makes sense. Not eager to post in fear of slipping up and can wait for hints in the wolf thread.

Sister Mary

Obviously... The only two people being pushed a lot today are Muriel and Sister Mary. I really would hate voting Muriel because she supports me 100% and I know I'm a villager--that's a strong tell for me because I'm so easy to vote for. Sister Mary hasn't done much to show that she is a villager so I'm fine voting her. And I would hate wasting my vote on a useless third possibility.

[Sir Percival]

lady liz
scarlet john's limited contribution ive like much more than liz's. dont think liz is scum, but dont think she help town either.

im assume that unless bert or will say otherwise that john not lying.

[Lady Elizabeth]

lady liz
scarlet john's limited contribution ive like much more than liz's. dont think liz is scum, but dont think she help town either.

im assume that unless bert or will say otherwise that john not lying.

Unless you assuming that John is village, this is extremely anti-town. To vote someone who you don't like, Ryan...

Anyway, John is very likely the watcher. Otherwise he would have assumed that Bert visted Young Will rather than the other way around. It would make a lot of sense for a wolf watcher to watch Bert because they might be able to find a Baner or something silly like that.

[Lady Elizabeth]

And the reason it's scummy as hell to demand I mod-kill myself is because the village reaction to players who are low activity is to try and push them into contributing something (which other players had done successfully.) I think they're trying to create a situation where I'm damned no matter what I do. If I don't post anything after being pushed I have to be lynched. If I do post something then I'm faking and have to be lynched. If I modkill myself instantly I'm dead and they can blame me. If not, then I have to be policy lynched. That's not scum hunting, it's trying to lock in a mislynch in such a way that I can't defend myself.

I didn't demand that you mod-kill yourself. I said it would be good if you would modkill. Mod-killing yourself on purpose is cheating because it basically hands the town a free lynch in this situation.

The fact that you say "they" implies a wolf conspiracy to get you modkilled which makes no-sense if you read the thread. Only Muriel is pushing you to get mod-killed. And the only other person who talked about its me. And I think Muriel pushed you because she read your post that you would not being posting at all.

If you didn't post anything you would get lynch one day. I disagree with you that if you post something you would get lynched. There are many times were a lurker got pushed, reacted and avoided the noose in these games.

If you modkill yourself that's good for wolfs. But they don't have that power. The mod would probably prod you to vote because he would consider modkilling yourself on purpose to be cheating; giving the town more lynches.

Only Muriel aggesively attacked you and that cannot be a conspiracy.

[Lady Elizabeth]

I believe John, and still don't see any evidence of guilt for him, so Lady Elizabeth.
Honestly, Will/Bert, I think you've easily said enough, that you might as well say the lot as its not going to fool the wolves any.

If you think that John is a villager. It is obviously better to kill me because he's a watcher do to what happened in the thread. I disagree though.

---

I've skimmed these pages and I love how people forgot the metagame argument that happened because of my first post...

[Sir Percival]

unsure on john, but have liked his contributions. also has strong claim that could be disproved by bert or will if lying.

guess im assuming john village unless bert or will disprove claim.

[Lady Elizabeth]

He hasn't mentioned Bert as a village lean either. Go and check his posts, the only mention I found of Bert was his first post where he voted Muriel because she had voted Bert due to his "I have a plan". Did you see something on Bert day 1 that I missed? If I was a watcher hoping to catch a wolf in the act of killing, Bert would not have been my first choice of who to watch.

Are you joking? Bert is the one i trust the most as villager. I think watching him is very logical action.

Lady Elizabeth picked a bad target to duel. I believe John, so i prefer he lives.

I'll just point out that I was pretty sure that he was a villager because it would not make sense for him to say "I'm in danger of being lynched" if he could just claim watcher.

Other possibility is that there is other member on team wolf who is the watcher and John just took the wolfs results to fake a power-role. That does not seem likely because if the wolf-watcher gets lynched John would get lynched quite quickly--as it's unlikely that there are copyies of two roles in this game.

[Lady Elizabeth]

unsure on john, but have liked his contributions. also has strong claim that could be disproved by bert or will if lying.

guess im assuming john village unless bert or will disprove claim.

I don't get this. John is telling the truth about who visited whom. If he were lying about it he would say that Bert visited Will. Because it's easier to assume that Bert scryed Will rather than Will proving his alignment to bert somehow. So John legitimately watched* Will visit Bert

*or had a wolf partner watch

[Lady Elizabeth]

The guy just outed our power role, on top of all the other stuff, and people are STILL believing he's a villager?

The smile does not seem to fit the style of someone irrationally angry like you. I still could just being seeing things though...