WW26: The Masquerade [Game Thread]

[Fat Rose]

And also, I've already clearly accepted that if i remained low activity I would have to be lynched at some point, so claiming that I'm trying to blame others for my low activity is fabricated nonsense as I have not done any such thing.

I didn't read anything posted pre-game start so I wasn't aware of the existence of a waiting list. If i knew there was one I'd have asked in-thread for replacement at the start of day

Finally, stop throwing insults and calling me a moron, or I will respond in kind, and I promise you won't like it at all.

I tremble with fear. But actually I didn't call you a moron, I wrote

If you are indeed the village watcher you are a moron to have gotten us in this situation to begin with.

And hey, if you are indeed the village watcher and played like that... well, I suppose...

[Muriel The Slow]

Finally, stop throwing insults and calling me a moron, or I will respond in kind, and I promise you won't like it at all.

If you are a villager, you are a moron. Do take that personally, it's meant to be. If you are a wolf, kudos to you, somehow you've managed to convince a few people of your innocence even in a situation like this.

Oh yeah? If you're a villager you're a fucking arrogant windbag with the intellectual capacity of a flea. A flea with brain cancer. That's also dead.

Mm-mm. You gotta work on your rage for the next game. That's too over the top, it doesn't feel real anymore.

[Bert The Bard]

This discussion is out of line, frankly. Also, it takes up valuable space and time.

Anybody got a tally?

[Muriel The Slow]

I do have a point about the rage. At the beginning of Day 2, when John came out with his statement, he understood why he looks suspicious and why we would want to lynch him. He was calm about it, and he accepted it. He was ready to die and be happy to not have to put time into this game. But when we actually started going through with it, he got angry. If he was honest in his first statement, why is he angry and fighting back so hard? When I had the misunderstanding with Saul, I felt terrible and really guilty about it. I apologized multiple times for that fight. If I was in John's place and I was a villager, I wouldn't be angry at everyone and lashing out. I would feel really bad for causing it all. I know, people are different. But to me, nothing that has happened makes sense if he was a villager, and everything makes sense if he was a wolf.

[Agnes The Orphan]

Just catching up:

If you think that John is a villager. It is obviously better to kill me because he's a watcher do to what happened in the thread. I disagree though.

This is what I believe: that he and you are about equal with regard to village lean - I wouldn't choose to lynch either but that's by the by - but he is both more valuable as a power role, and contributing better IMO. Yes this is with a fraction of your spam.

I've skimmed these pages and I love how people forgot the metagame argument that happened because of my first post...

I love how you forget that I (and others) strongly disagreed with that meta...

I'll just point out that I was pretty sure that he was a villager because it would not make sense for him to say "I'm in danger of being lynched" if he could just claim watcher.

You mean wolf right? If so, this is a horrible reason to put your life on the line to lynch someone - hell, its not even worth a vote. People can still be lynched with a powerrole, especially ones that are alignment ambiguous like watcher. And yet you jump to him a s a wolf because of it.

[Agnes The Orphan]

I think Will is scum. Bert pops up and claims Will is villager. So far so good but then he adds. If Will is scum then the GM is a Bastard. Did you see that?

This sentence shws that Bert is not that sure that Will is a villager at all.
And John comes and claims that Will visited Bert not the other way round.
Bert who was visited claims that Will is town except if the GM is a Bastard (nice way out). And you wonder why I want to hear the full story?
Even if Will is a neighborizer I don't see why the GM would be a bastard if Will is scum nor how Bert can be sure enough that Will is a villager to make that unnecessary claim.
TLDR: I want an explanation for If Will is scum then the GM is a Bastard
PS There is a sinister explanation but I prefer to hear from Bert/Will first.

I think we're seeing a mason pair who count as visiting one another for purposes of watcher. I think they claimed prematurely and fluffed it up, and I think the GM is a bastard was not giving an out but referring to boasted games (the only sort where one is lied to in pms) which I severely doubt this is.

[Agnes The Orphan]

Finally, stop throwing insults and calling me a moron, or I will respond in kind, and I promise you won't like it at all.

If you are a villager, you are a moron. Do take that personally, it's meant to be. If you are a wolf, kudos to you, somehow you've managed to convince a few people of your innocence even in a situation like this.

This is NOT the right attitude for these games, Muriel.

+1
Muriel, please drag your feelings out of this, and stop taking everything as a personal insult.

[Fat Rose]

Unofficial Tally:

Sister Mary (7) - Know-Nothing Jon, (Doctor Saul), Fat Rose, Muriel the Slow, Half-Nose Harry, Lady Elizabeth, Bert the Bard
Muriel the Slow (4) - Sir Percival, Rob the Filch, Short Richard, Kate the Waif
Kate the Waif (1) - Widow Edith

*Doctor Saul in brackets because I can't find that vote but it was in the official tally
--------

Scarlet John (8) - Bert the Bard, Fat Rose, Know-Nothing Jon, Muriel the Slow, Half-Nose Harry, Young Will, Kate the Waif, Lady Elizabeth
Lady Elizabeth (6) - Scarlet John, Widow Edith, Doctor Saul, Agnes the Orphan, Short Richard, Sir Percival

[Agnes The Orphan]

@Muriel, he's being angry because you keep pushing him for (IMO) very stupid reasons and arguing with him. The two of you are bouncing off of each other in a bad way.
I think the whole revealing roles thing has been handled badly, but I don't feel it casts suspicion on anyone.
Hmm. Currently feeling it for Kate the Waif for her posts a couple of pages back (51) which talks about being annoyed when I don't think she'd posted before that and the basic unemotional theme to it anyway. Ok that sounds worse now I've said it

[Fat Rose]

+1
Muriel, please drag your feelings out of this, and stop taking everything as a personal insult.

Quite honestly, I think you are addressing the wrong person or at least you have to address several more. Rob for example who told us

You can kiss my ass, kiss my ass, kiss my ass.

In German we would say "Du kannst mich am Arsch lecken", what is a very rude insult. Or Scarlet John asking Half-Nose Harry

Do you have half a brain in addition to half a nose?

which I would also count as an insult and emotional response.