WW26: The Masquerade [Game Thread]

[Widow Edith]

GG Bert

It was a pleasure playing with you.

:salute:

[Widow Edith]

And to continue where I was before the game stopped:

Rob the Filch

[Widow Edith]

@KN-Jon

I agree on Kate (although she made an huge effort during the night) and Richard. Don't know about Sir Percival and HN-Harry

Obviously we disagree on Rob.


@Dr Saul: Please spill the beans so that the Muriel case can finally laid at rest. Why did you risk getting nightkilled with your information (= why didn't you make a last-minute post like KN-Jon)?

[Know-Nothing Jon]

GG, Bert.

My previous post was what I wrote up last night when the thread was closed. My opinions haven't changed much after mulling it over for 24 hours, though.

One thing I did reconsider is the thing about Rob asking to be replaced - I can agree with Bert that it's more of a null tell, considering that the game has been paused due to apparent "issues". Rob might ask to be replaced as scum if he was feeling unfairly screwed over by the GM. That said, he's always shown great will to win as scum, including the game where I was scum with him, so I think it would take quite a lot before he'd quit in disgust.

Anyway, enough about that. (Or actually, previewing, what is your take on it, Edith?)

I'll vote for Half-Nose Harry because he just made one big post yesterday and it was basically a summary of the suspicions that were put forth by everybody else.

[Bert The Bard]

Thanks for the game, everyone.

[Know-Nothing Jon]

@KN-Jon

I agree on Kate (although she made an huge effort during the night) and Richard. Don't know about Sir Percival and HN-Harry

Obviously we disagree on Rob.


@Dr Saul: Please spill the beans so that the Muriel case can finally laid at rest. Why did you risk getting nightkilled with your information (= why didn't you make a last-minute post like KN-Jon)?

Cross-posted with this despite previewing.

Good question about Dr. Saul there. I'll try to reevaluate Rob once again after we've heard a bit from him today.

[Young Will]

widow edith

more come come tonight

[Muriel The Slow]

Before he posts the evidence, I want to bring up a thought that came to my mind during the break. I realized that the evidence might not exist, which would explain why it was not brought up when I was on the chopping block on Day 2. It would also explain why he didn't post the evidence before the night lynch, which would have been the logical thing to do since the wolves would want to kill anyone who has evidence to clear me. Hopefully Saul will have the evidence and clears me, and possibly himself depending on what it is. If not, I find something fishy about it all.

[Know-Nothing Jon]

I'll vote for Half-Nose Harry because he just made one big post yesterday and it was basically a summary of the suspicions that were put forth by everybody else.

Rereading a bit, this isn't entirely accurate. I still don't like his big post, but he did follow up with a little more content and engaged in the debate around Scarlet John.

So on reflection, Short Richard may be a better vote.

[Muriel The Slow]

Night 2 only one kill and Bert's role flip prove that it's a single WW faction, description of his role here. He must have used his vig-shot on Night 1, along with a second vig-shot by the village. One of them hit a wolf, so kudos to whoever made that shot.