WW26: The Masquerade [Game Thread]

[Know-Nothing Jon]

This is stupid. I am not a fool. It does not say fool in my PM. It says seer

Do you know what a fool is?

[Doctor Saul]

I am not a wolf! Now we are going to lose because someone messed with my night 2 result.

[Doctor Saul]

This is stupid. I am not a fool. It does not say fool in my PM. It says seer

Do you know what a fool is?

They said earlier that a fool gets opposite results. But if i am a seer a get same result, right?

[Muriel The Slow]

This is stupid. I am not a fool. It does not say fool in my PM. It says seer

That's what a fool is. A fool thinks he's a seer, but he doesn't get accurate results. In your case, if you are a fool, it would specifically be completely random results. That's why it's a bastard role to put in the game, the game master lies to the player. It's probably a bit more reasonable if there is a real seer as well to balance things out, but if we had one, he would have spoken out before we lynched Kate. If you really are a villager and the fool, don't worry man, you played everything exactly as you should have. It's not your fault we got screwed.

Muriel, if Will is a friendly neighbor like you presume, how does that make him "not exactly confirmed"?

Because there is the chance that he is a scum-aligned friendly neighbor. I don't know if there is some other term for the scum version. We had a seer, a double voter and a few very strong villager lean players already out in the open, it's not like hiding his role would help the village at this point since the wolves have so many other juicy targets. If he was a villager friendly neighbor, he should have revealed it when I asked, since there is no reason to hide it, and every reason to reveal it.

[Know-Nothing Jon]

A fool is told that he is a seer but actually isn't. He could get random results, or opposite results, or all innocent, or all guilty. In your case it must be either random or opposite. Or you're a wolf.

[Know-Nothing Jon]

Well, a scum-aligned friendy neighbor must be the ultimate bastard role so it sounds implausible to me. I don't think Young Will has withheld any information that he should have shared, if he is a friendly neighbor. And that is still just speculation on your part, if I understand correctly. Not that I can really see what else he would be.

I did ask him to explain why he chose to visit Bert, so it would be nice if he could explain that. Also, did he visit anyone else on night 2?

[Doctor Saul]

So i would not know i was a fool? That's dumb.
I must be a random fool then
Sorry Kate

[Half-Nose Harry]

I really can't see Will being a wolf friendly neighbor. I was suspicious of him up until Bert cleared him, and even then somewhat until Bert flipped town. Once I knew for a fact that Bert was town, then I have to assume Will is innocent. A scum aligned friendly neighbor seems like it would be a very nasty role to have in a game, and if that's the case we're probably screwed anyways, since we have enough issues as it is. I really don't know what to think about Saul. I don't see why wolves would offer him up for one sure mislynch, and yes him flipping scum would mean that Muriel is suspect again, but she was already very heavily suspected by many, so that wouldn't gain them anything they didn't already have. That being said, I don't see how we can not lynch him at this point.

[Muriel The Slow]

Well no matter what anyone believes, Will shouldn't in any case be the first one to be targeted after we lynch Saul. There are other wolves, ones that actually have content that we can analyze and are less of a risk to lynch. I didn't have any reason to postpone posting my thoughts on him, so I didn't, and as I've said I think it's better that everyone knows what his interaction with Bert was and that he isn't a 100% confirmed villager.

[Know-Nothing Jon]

I must be a random fool then

Why?