WW26 Lurker Thread

[Ichabod]

I'm loving this new crazy theory. It accounts for the three deaths on Night 1: Agnes kills Old Tom or Simple Anne by misfired vig shot, then Easy Sarah decides to sacrifice herself to possess Saul after being totally called out by Simple Anne night 1. She might have figured that she was going to be lynched otherwise.

The actual switch looks like it happened at Saul's post #594/595, or maybe #571, which I think is mid-Day 2. Delayed action possession?

I guess maybe Saul just asked to be replaced. But if he was taken over by a ghost Sarah, then it might mean the the village hasn't actually managed to kill a single wolf yet. Hah!

Or maybe Saul just forgot how to spell...

Not gonna comment on kills () but I don't think Sarah was caught out by Anne N1.
This was the Anne that everyone was thinking about policy lynching remember.

And possession is a mechanic that's way too bastard for BRick IMO.

Hey, hey, hey. If I had been playing on day 1, we'd have a wolf dead. That post from Sarah I quoted was obvious wolf and I wouldn't let that slip. But, oh well, someone had to kill me, hopefully not a villager. This policy lynching/vigging thing has gotten too exaggerated - one weekend more busy than normal and I have to be killed? What's the point?

[Gaspar]

I stopped reading the thread after day 1, because as I said, too hard to lurk.

But if you had 100 of these games, scum would win 95 of them. Once you introduce an unknown roleplay element, its a million times easier for scum to hide.

I also think you should absolutely post all of the identities of the players at the end - the damage of bad behavior to your reputation as a RB'er is part of what keeps our games relatively civil.

I confess that all of this might be me talking out of my ass, since as I said, I haven't read the game thread since the first day.

[Ichabod]

Well, for anyone that still haven't realzied, I was

Simple Anne, the one who wasn't there

[BRickAstley]

Like I said before the game for people who want to know identities: I'm not giving out who anyone is before end of the game, I'm leaving that up to the players' choice, but I'll post who everyone was when the game ends.

[Easy Sarah]

Your presence turns our dreams to tatters, but good advice Easy Sarah.

I've been told that I break hearts, but for non-corporeal beings, I'll have to settle for crushing dreams.

[Lady Elizabeth]

I have to call BS about Muriel being lynched for being an a-hole. Remember the Civilization werewolf game were I acted like a total a-hole and beat Slowcheetah. Muriel got lynched because of Saul. Muriel was a sink for votes because here posts sounded insincere. This was because she was roleplaying an a-hole character when she really wasn't one. This makes ALL her posts a lie and this is very bad for village. Remember what they say: lynch all liars.

[Ichabod]

Like I said before the game for people who want to know identities: I'm not giving out who anyone is before end of the game, I'm leaving that up to the players' choice, but I'll post who everyone was when the game ends.

Ah, sorry for pestering you about it, BRick. I read Molach's comment as if you had given him the names and I thought there wasn't a problem. My apologies.

[Agnes The Orphan]

I wasn't even talking about your bad logic, simply the tone of your posts...

Ichabod:

I didn't vig you, nor would I for that.
I'm just saying that people were unlikely to listen to you or follow up because you weren't saying much. If you caught Sarah (I honestly can't remember) then they probably killed you.

[Commodore]

I sense hubristic scum now.

Village is already being much much more constructive. Muriel should have been dueled away long ago; would have massively helped the village.

[Lady Elizabeth]

If Richard doesn't show up; the village has to kill him.