WW27 Game Thread: Once there were 12

[Azza]

Voting for you is a day action. I'm not sure how you're getting he's going to night kill you out of that.

Who said anything about a night kill?
Perhaps I worded that wrong though, I meant the lynch that happens at the end of Day 2.
What do you think of the actual slip?

Your posting style both this game and the masquerade game has been highly abrasive. I wouldn't go so far as to say you're trying to get lynched, but I do actually agree with Q's general idea.

[Jowy]

Voting for you is a day action. I'm not sure how you're getting he's going to night kill you out of that.

Who said anything about a night kill?
Perhaps I worded that wrong though, I meant the lynch that happens at the end of Day 2.
What do you think of the actual slip?

Your posting style both this game and the masquerade game has been highly abrasive. I wouldn't go so far as to say you're trying to get lynched, but I do actually agree with Q's general idea.

Okay you missed it. My point was that the quote reads like he knows I'm a villager, despite the fact that the rest of his posts say I'm scum. If I'm a wolf who tries to get lynched, why would I arrogantly laugh at the villagers when I'm lynched?

[Azza]

Yeah I'm not seeing it.

[Jkaen]

Jowy, I understand the point you are making, but I think you see a tell due to standard defensive bias. Not surprised you see something, but don't agree with it. To be honest thinking its a tell gives me a slight town lean for that post

[novice]

Zak and Novice, what do you think about Mattimeo's posts today?

Well I don't like how he piled on Jowy with a falsehood and when asked why says that he was bullshitting.

Other than that he has commented a little here and there, and I agree that he hasn't chosen the most helpful things to comment on. It's pretty much in character for Mattimeo, unfortunately, but I'm not averse to voting him.

I see what Jowy means about Q's slip - I'll let Q answer that himself.

As for Jowy, the feeling I get is that he never admits when he's wrong. So he'd rather dig in on an unreasonable stance (which I find scummy) than actually engage in discussion. So I'm having a hard time determining if he's squirming scum or stubborn villager.

Azarius - Neutral leaning to town. Don't have much to say about him - he's been quietish, but reasonable seeming. No scum tells after that post I talked abotu Day 1, and that was pretty weak anyway. Probably deserves another look sometime.

I have to do my own review on Azarius, but if your description of "quietish, but reasonable seeming" is correct that's a bit of a warning light.

So yeah... Balancing for my various biases I actually think Mattimeo deserves my vote.

[novice]

To be honest thinking its a tell gives me a slight town lean for that post

I agree, with the standard disclaimer that it could be cleverly faked.

[Azza]

Mattimeo unless he has a good reason I shouldn't vote for him in the next 50 minutes.

[Azza]

So, my vote is pretty much process of elimination. Gazglum I strongly lean town, Jkaen slight town lean, Azarius no current suspicion. Zak and novice I can't get a read on so far because the arguments exchanged with MJW and Jowy are a chore to try to read. At this stage, I can't distinguish between which of those two is more likely to be disruptive scum and disruptive villager. Don't like Qgqqqqq, but can't justify voting for him, particularly when there's no clear support. So that leaves Mattimeo, who hasn't sat right with the things he's been saying.

Not great logic, but it seems the best way to go today.

[Jowy]

I've got mixed feelings on Matt. He's got an attitude problem, he hasn't pursued any cases and has played a reactionary game. I wasn't a fan of the vote on MJW, due to the reason being that MJW is anti-town, though Matt did mention that he had nothing solid to go with and only voted because no-lynch was not an option. At least the MJW vote is significantly more townish than if he had voted for CH, who turned out villager and was the one he was racing against. We've quite firmly seen that the majority thinks that players should answer questions that they are asked of, and Matt does this. On one hand he is doing what the players want and not being evasive, but on the other hand spending all his online time on questions casts a bad light on him because he's not scum hunting. As for his answers, I like them. There are some Day 1 stuff that I disagree with, but I didn't find any of his answers scummy. I think all in all, he's got a slight village lean in my eyes.

[Jowy]

Whoops, forgot to say that I believe his lack of time and his attitude to be real and not faked.