WW29: Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood

[Serdoa]

So, conclusion after rereading: I don't like Jkaens play so far. His attack on me was imo not really warranted. He basically voted for me because he concluded that I voted for MJW for anti-town behaviour. Not only wouldn't I agree with that, but it was a night vote. While he counts my vote as if it has some kind of extremely high value despite being done in the night he himself made a similar vote (just in bold instead of red...) but claims now he tried to fish for reactions. I explained in the last post why I don't believe him. Besides that night-post and subsequent claims of fishing for reaction or stating the reactions (which basically is just 9 times: ignored me...) I don't see much content either. So

Jkaen

One other point: It gives me pause that Lewwyn is so active already, given that we normally don't see much from him before later in the game. Given that this game started with so few players though, he doesn't have more than a day to get started. So that's not a scum-tell for me, more something that makes me wary of his reads because he might step up his play knowing that the time-line is rather short while not being suited for that.

(Basically I don't trust that Lewwyn is a good player before he didn't have a day or two to get 'in touch' with the game)

... anyway who is second on your list if no one else votes for Jkaen. It is too easy for scum if we don't consolidate.

Jkaen -> Meiz -> Jowy / Goreripper -> Mattimeo / novice -> MJW / zakalwe / Lewwyn

(Meiz because he didn't really add much and I feel he jumped on a few questionable ideas, like that from Jowy)

[Jowy]

Yes Serdoa, if Rowain had grilled someone else, then the same would stand for them. GoreRipper was the only one. Rowain did go for MJW at first, but then admitted that his case against MJW is weak. MJW had nothing to fear from him.

[Meiz]

Serdoa why are you putting Matt so low on your preference?

[Meiz]

I also wonder why you commented on my night kill speculation and say how it's bad to just go with that. Yet you ignore my follow up posts and just state I haven't added much. I'm well past the night kill and seriously wonder how you missed that.

[Serdoa]

Meiz, if I missed something, it may well be because I re-read at work while being constantly bothered with people asking me stuff and having meetings. Just to give you an idea, I started with my re-read at 9:30 in the morning, yet my post was in the afternoon. I will take a second look at your posts specifically.

As for why Matt is so low on my lynch-preference: Because he sounds like Matt to me. Less meta-ish but there isn't a whole bunch of meta to discuss, so he simply shuts up for the most part and waits to get to a later stage were he feels less lost. If you check a few of the last games you will see that my attitude towards Matt is general to give him more leeway at the start because he gets easily lynched just for being him.

[BRickAstley]

Tally as of post 235:

2 votes: Goreripper (Mattimeo, Jowy)
2 votes: MJW (novice, zakalwe)
2 votes: zakalwe (MJW (ya that one), Lewwyn)
1 votes: Serdoa (Jkaen)
1 votes: Mattimeo (Meiz)
1 votes: Jowy (Goreripper)
1 votes: Jkaen (Serdoa)

Voting history:

zak

goreripper

GoreRipper

Lewwyn

Zak

Serdoa

Serdoa

zakalwe

Zakalwe

Serdoa

Novice

Goreripper

Meiz

Lewwyn

Mattimeo

Mattimeo

Zakalwe

Goreripper

Jowy

GoreRipper

MJW

MJW

zakalwe

Jkaen

GM note, it looks like the tool orders votes in the listing as to who got voted first, so the posted order is correct for tiebreakers (Goreripper would be lynched over MJW would be lynched over zakalwe right now).

2.133 Hours Remaining.

[Goreripper]

Thank you Brick. I do not like either other but MJW is a little more likely to be mafia if novice is right.

[Goreripper]

But I would still feel better about Jowy or Serdoa.

[novice]

In the event that two or more players are tied for the most votes, the tied player that reached their current vote total first is lynched. (A gets to 4 votes first, B gets to 4 votes later in the day ∴ A is lynched).

Quick comment, Mafia Helper's tallies do not follow this rule. Pretty sure Zak got to two votes before MJW.

[zakalwe]

Thank you Brick. I do not like either other but MJW is a little more likely to be mafia if novice is right.

MJW definitely is a thinking being, if that's what you're referring to.