WW 31 Game Thread PARANOIA

[Ichabod]

I'll always vote to lynch a player because I'm here to play the game, not to watch it.

[Azza]

1 votes: BrickAstley (Azza) (Just so you know you can't really lynch me )

That's what you want me to think.


Normally I find no lynch suggestions to be suspicious, but Bob makes a decent case for it. Still not going to vote for it, but I'm not going to vote for Bob because of it either.

MJW seems to be more meta-crazy than usual, like he's playing it up for the crowd.

[Ryan]

I dont like the bandwagon on MJW.

[Gazglum]

Bob, your logic makes sense, but reasons of sportsmanship and roleplay mean that we have to lynch. As Happiness Officer, I need to push for what will make the group happiest, and I think we all know that Happiness is a Dead Commie. The second-best option is to die gloriously for Friend Computer, so even a mislynch is happier than not doing our duty!

But it's really great that you're throwing up these ideas for discussion.

Merovech and Azarius haven't offered us anything much yet, but the second day is just getting rolling so I expect to see them chime in soon. Mattimeo is playing the strong, silent, leadership card, which is great and I'm sure he'll step in to guide us before the end. I'll hold off on Old Harry until he's had a chance to respond to some of the points made to him, MJW seems in character, and I think Jowy is being helpful and desesrves a pat on the back.

Lacking any obvious tells like hammers and sickles being found in people's personnell lockers, I'll vote Zakalwe for making lots of 'maybe X could be scummy' musings without following up with the big red pencil.

Zak, you haven't shifted your first vote yet. Does that mean you think Merovech is genuinely most suspect still?

[Lewwyn]

Okay, I thought Catwalk's and Old Harry's explanation to assuming Zak and Azarius are town was along the line of my own thinking, that if Lewwyn is scum, he wouldn't call out his scum buddies like that. They did quote my post, after all. I'd imagine it would be pretty easy to just say that yeah, this is why I assumed they were town. But Catwalk did not do that, he avoided the question and says it doesn't matter. It's a pretty subtle thing, but I think a townie would just answer it truthfully, while scum might be more inclined to do what Catwalk did so that they don't have to lie about it.

Say what now?

If Jowy starts making sense and contributing in a significant way, he's scum. So don't worry about it Catwalk.

[Catwalk]

Mattimeo is playing the strong, silent, leadership card, which is great and I'm sure he'll step in to guide us before the end. I'll hold off on Old Harry until he's had a chance to respond to some of the points made to him

Silent play is good? Silence is terrible for the town. Mattimeo has played an early silent wolf before, don't let him get away with it. And Harry has had plenty chance to respond to the points against him, he chose to mostly ignore him. I'm questioning your judgement, Happiness Officer

[Lewwyn]

or at the very least call me an imbecile. I'm actually a little hurt by that

It's been a while since we played WW. We have some guests in the thread(sunrise), and I'm trying to be more Zen again. If people think this is a scum tell, then I'm establishing a new village baseline.

[Lewwyn]

Mattimeo is playing the strong, silent, leadership card, which is great and I'm sure he'll step in to guide us before the end. I'll hold off on Old Harry until he's had a chance to respond to some of the points made to him

Silent play is good? Silence is terrible for the town. Mattimeo has played an early silent wolf before, don't let him get away with it. And Harry has had plenty chance to respond to the points against him, he chose to mostly ignore him. I'm questioning your judgement, Happiness Officer

Mattimeo plays silent pretty often. Even as village. But it's only been half a day. I bet he posts again before the end of the day.

[Lewwyn]

Didn't respond to this earlier, but

[quote='Jowy' pid='450093' dateline='1389964737'
Novice already picked up on it, but Lewwyn was quick to call out town leans on Azarius and Zak. Would be a little naive to think that Scum-Lewwyn would call out his scum buddies so obviously, so I don't think that's it. But it was still a little strange. Maybe he's just in a good mood, in which case I should try not to ruin it right away :lol:
[/quote]

I actually am in a good mood. Today I start vacation for the next month and a half.

[Gazglum]

Silent play is good? Silence is terrible for the town. Mattimeo has played an early silent wolf before, don't let him get away with it. And Harry has had plenty chance to respond to the points against him, he chose to mostly ignore him. I'm questioning your judgement, Happiness Officer

Just trying to put a good spin on things Catwalk! I'm assuming that Old Harry has been asleep/unavailable, and will be posting again shortly. I agree that we should all be chit-chatting today!