WW 31 Game Thread PARANOIA

[Mattimeo]

also: damnit, I was looking forward to the carnage tonight, with Lewwyn shooting twice in addition to all the other sources of kills...

[zakalwe]

And Jowy is my pick for serial killer of fun games.

Ok, I didn't parse that correctly the first time around. I guess it wasn't all your fault, then.

Gazglum

Let's see if Lewwyn actually was a bad guy, then. Seemed to me like his story was falling apart a bit before this interruption.

[Jowy]

It's very unlikely that Jowy is scum unless there are two teams. It's very unlikely the people on the same team would allow someone to get killed. They would just make Jowy stop attacking.

The last part assumes that Lewwyn is scum so how do you know that?

Nice catch there. If Lewwyn flips scum, I suppose you have to lynch both of us since MJW was defending me, but 1 for 1 is still good. Hopefully he's not a town who just misspoke horribly or it would be a disaster :P

[zakalwe]

Definitely either Gazglum or Bob, at any rate. One is claiming compulsive vig and the other is claiming limited-shots vig. I strongly doubt we have both.

[zakalwe]

I'm not sure you are reading MJW correctly, but he should explain it himself.

[Gazglum]

And Jowy is my pick for serial killer of fun games.

Ok, I didn't parse that correctly the first time around. I guess it wasn't all your fault, then.

Gazglum

Let's see if Lewwyn actually was a bad guy, then. Seemed to me like his story was falling apart a bit before this interruption.

I find it hard to beleive Lewwyn would abandon his team if he was a communist. He could be a serial killer I guess.

Zak, why pick me over Bob? Given the amount of pressure/defence I have already been doing, it seems that Bob should have his turn in the spotlight. And why would I counterclaim and make it a 2 man show if I was scum? Yes, I was going to get pressure today, but with 18 people still in the running, Scumglum would have to be pretty neurotic to think that he was that certainly going to be the lynch target today. Whereas by counterclaiming Bob I admit that I am pretty much sealing my demise tomorrow if he is lynched and flips Troubleshooter.

I'm going to bed, but I think Friends of Friend Computer shoudl take the time to look at Bob's posts with a more sceptical eye. NObody has really posted an analysis yet. I'll take a look myself tomorrow.

I don't understand why anyone would protect Old Harry so Gazglum is probably a wolf.

Nobody would have. That's one reason (not the top) that I pushed him yesterday, because if he was protected, it would only have been by a scumbuddy. HIm being doctored by town, or me being blocked both seem unlikely. So I am assuming that he was jailed by someone who thought he might be a communist. It's kind of a moot point now.

Rowain, did you ever respond abotu your thoguhts on Serdoa?

And there is still a lot of lurking happening. You can't say hooray if won't play, Sunrise.

[Rowain]

Rowain, did you ever respond abotu your thoguhts on Serdoa?

Gazglum I consider you a smart guy I'm sure you can figure out my reasons. And then try to explain why you attacked Serdoa.

[Catwalk]

I hope neither of you will quit. If anything cool down and quit talking to/about each other for a bit. I, for one, appreciate Lewwyn's calmer style. He may well have bullied you in previous games Jowy (I've been on the butt end of that myself), I'm not seeing it in this game. MJW, it's ridiculous to suspect Qg for logging on and not posting. I do that myself from work, I have time to check on occasion but usually can't post (skipping my lunch break today). I don't think it makes you scum, but I do think it makes you misguided. I think Lewwyn is likely to be a serial killer, especially with his early emphasis that he didn't think there were any 3rd party players. I still don't understand where he got that notion from, it seems a lot like an attempt to poke our thoughts away from looking for serial killers. That said, I don't think it's particularly important to lynch him right away. If he's serial killer he'll go after both town and scum (and won't know who's who anyway), and he may still be town. I can't see him being scum.

And I just saw that Lewwyn has quit for good... sucks, but let's carry on with the game and keep it civil this time. I also don't think going after the confessed vigs is an urgent priority, I find it unlikely that scum would subject themselves to scrutiny that way. I'm going to vote Serdoa unless Rowain wants to offer any information as to why we shouldn't hang him.

[zakalwe]

I find it unlikely that scum would subject themselves to scrutiny that way.

Well, Bob didn't exactly have a choice in the matter, since Ryan told us he can kill. As for Gazglum sticking his neck out, my thinking is that he felt certain Serdoa would be springing a tracking result on him soon, anyway. So by counterclaiming he could take the initiative. I have by no means decided yet, though. The day is still young.

[Rowain]

I'm going to vote Serdoa unless Rowain wants to offer any information as to why we shouldn't hang him.

Thats your reason to lynch someone? Really? Looks like Ichabod has been right on D1 again.