WW 31 Game Thread PARANOIA

[Catwalk]

While there may only be one scum faction, there could very well be a recruiter. Would fit perfectly in a role madness game. Did Rowain's read on Serdoa or vice versa change markedly from D1 to D2?

[Catwalk]

And given that we know there are mutants around (shown by the presence of anti mutant cream), mutants sound a lot like recruiters. Serdoa, I don't think you and Rowain are both communists. It is highly suspicious that he strongly recommended that we don't lynch you, and then later explains it with "he seems like a good guy to me". Rowain must have something on you.

[novice]

I don't know, Catwalk, and I don't know Serdoa. Frankly I don't care about theorycrafting around this. My point is simply that in a role madness game like this where multiple scum factions have been confirmed you don't let an intervention like Rowain's slide. It's not believable that Rowain decided to intervene like he did solely based on a read, and I'm amazed that Ichabod is the only one to agree. Let's get Rowain's role out in the open.

[Serdoa]

He was questioning me still on D2 catwalk. And I answered him (and others).

novice as I see your newest post: Please show me the post that shows that multiple scum factions have been confirmed. I haven't seen anything like that.

[Serdoa]

And given that we know there are mutants around (shown by the presence of anti mutant cream), mutants sound a lot like recruiters. Serdoa, I don't think you and Rowain are both communists. It is highly suspicious that he strongly recommended that we don't lynch you, and then later explains it with "he seems like a good guy to me". Rowain must have something on you.

He doesn't to my knowledge. I know where he was on N1 and that was not me.

(And btw I don't get why you believe he can't come around on me. I mean apart from my arguments being truthful and it being dumb to believe I would set my life on these arguments as scum instead of coming up with shit, what I easily could have, Rowain and I know each other from other games, both together as scum and village. I think he can read me pretty good, probably because he can see behind my bad English and knowing my mother-language he can better grasp what I meant to say.)

[novice]

Three night kills, Lewwyn and Bob both claim not to have killed, and commies only have one kill.

So best case scenario there's one scum faction and a serial killer.

Speaking of which it's mystifying that people are voting to lynch Gazglum when we can just wait and see how Lewwyn flips.

[novice]

(And btw I don't get why you believe he can't come around on me. I mean apart from my arguments being truthful and it being dumb to believe I would set my life on these arguments as scum instead of coming up with shit, what I easily could have, Rowain and I know each other from other games, both together as scum and village. I think he can read me pretty good, probably because he can see behind my bad English and knowing my mother-language he can better grasp what I meant to say.)

That's fine Serdoa but do you really think he would put his neck on the line and tell everybody not to lynch you until Day 6? That's just antitown, if you happen to be scum he goes down with you.

I don't really understand why you're arguing this on Rowain's behalf.

[Serdoa]

I don't know, Catwalk, and I don't know Serdoa. Frankly I don't care about theorycrafting around this. My point is simply that in a role madness game like this where multiple scum factions have been confirmed you don't let an intervention like Rowain's slide. It's not believable that Rowain decided to intervene like he did solely based on a read, and I'm amazed that Ichabod is the only one to agree. Let's get Rowain's role out in the open.

Also, I don't like this post. I think there are several points to make:

1.) You ignore the points that I raised because they destroy your argument. You wave them away by calling it theorycrafting when it isn't. These are direct arguments from stuff that happened in this game. Not some theories about what could be, but obvious points about why something can't be. Ignoring those like you did is in itself scum-behaviour.

2.) You insist that multiple scum factions have been confirmed when that is not in the slightest the case. That's a blatant lie to give your point more credence because you really want to know if Rowain is a seer. Again, role-fishing -> scum

In general, I think you do try to deflect attention away from your scum-buddy, given the current vote-count that has to be Gazglum. Gazglum already complained yesterday when he felt my theory needed him and you to both be scum but I think you both (especially Gazglum, but you too) have played very obviously like a team. I think also that you know indeed that there are multiple scum factions, hence why you claim it that vehemently, but Azza was part of yours and you are already going down. That leads to this "Hail Mary" attempt by you now to save Gazglum, because you know if he dies you are next, just because of the way he interacted with you and how you have several times on D2 already deflected for him. I realized that, and I'm sure I'm not the only one who did.

[Catwalk]

And given that we know there are mutants around (shown by the presence of anti mutant cream), mutants sound a lot like recruiters. Serdoa, I don't think you and Rowain are both communists. It is highly suspicious that he strongly recommended that we don't lynch you, and then later explains it with "he seems like a good guy to me". Rowain must have something on you.

He doesn't to my knowledge. I know where he was on N1 and that was not me.

(And btw I don't get why you believe he can't come around on me. I mean apart from my arguments being truthful and it being dumb to believe I would set my life on these arguments as scum instead of coming up with shit, what I easily could have, Rowain and I know each other from other games, both together as scum and village. I think he can read me pretty good, probably because he can see behind my bad English and knowing my mother-language he can better grasp what I meant to say.)

I can easily believe him coming around on you. I cannot believe him making a strong recommendation for all to not lynch you without anything to back it up. It strongly hints at other information about you.

[MJW (ya that one)]

Three night kills, Lewwyn and Bob both claim not to have killed, and commies only have one kill.

So best case scenario there's one scum faction and a serial killer.

Speaking of which it's mystifying that people are voting to lynch Gazglum when we can just wait and see how Lewwyn flips.

Why does it matter what lewwyn flips?

Serdoa visted lewwyn who didn't move. Unless mattimeo is a roleblocker it's unlikely lewwyn is scum who threw away a night-kill.