WW 31 Game Thread PARANOIA

[Catwalk]

I would also like to know what evidence you have of multiple scum factions novice, I don't see any confirmation anywhere. Plenty hints, but no confirmation.

[Serdoa]

Three night kills, Lewwyn and Bob both claim not to have killed, and commies only have one kill.

So best case scenario there's one scum faction and a serial killer.

Speaking of which it's mystifying that people are voting to lynch Gazglum when we can just wait and see how Lewwyn flips.

Um, best case scenario: one scum faction. Your own words. (A serial killer obviously can't be Rowain AND me...). Before though you claimed that we definitely have multiple scum factions, with Rowain and me being part of a two-man one. That does not match up novice.

Also I pointed out earlier that commies could have more than one kill (one factional, one or several personal). I guess you missed that post.

That's fine Serdoa but do you really think he would put his neck on the line and tell everybody not to lynch you until Day 6? That's just antitown, if you happen to be scum he goes down with you.

Yes, I do think he would. I would do the same right now for one or two others. Look, he didn't write "Don't lynch him ever" (which would indicate a result on me) but "Don't lynch him now". I'm baffled that it seems you all believe he had some result when his own words pretty much indicated that he just didn't think it is the right move to lynch me at that point when all I did pointed in the opposite direction, except for my vote on D1. I'm actually surprised that no one seem to get that it makes no sense for me to play the way I did as scum. I am easily able to work that situation much better as scum.

I don't really understand why you're arguing this on Rowain's behalf.

See my last post, because I believe you are scum.

[Catwalk]

I would ask every villager to leave Serdoa and not lynch him. Not today not tomorrow and maybe not on D5.

These were his words. It goes well beyond "let's not lynch him now, I have a hunch he's innocent".

[Bobchillingworth]

Speaking of which it's mystifying that people are voting to lynch Gazglum when we can just wait and see how Lewwyn flips.

What is the difference between Gazglum and me in your reasoning? We're both mostly suspected of being SK, right? - Gazglum by his own admission, and me because I've got a kill power and revealed I'm a vig under duress, but also helped lynch Azza. We could both be innocent for all you know, unless you do know more than you're letting on- maybe the village should lynch you, who plenty thought were scummy yesterday, and then any scum-revealing scanners we have can hit me and/or Gazglum. I volunteer myself, in fact- I have nothing to hide. I'll even scrub myself, if people are worried I'm a SK- I don't mind holding off with my vig shots for another night.

[Ichabod]

I would ask every villager to leave Serdoa and not lynch him. Not today not tomorrow and maybe not on D5.

These were his words. It goes well beyond "let's not lynch him now, I have a hunch he's innocent".

[Bobchillingworth]

I would also like to know what evidence you have of multiple scum factions novice, I don't see any confirmation anywhere. Plenty hints, but no confirmation.

If he's a commie, it would seem natural to him if he *knew* his faction was only getting in one kill a night.


The rules do imply a second killer faction- commies only get one shot a night with their special team power. But there could be a commie with a vig-type shot as well, which could serve as balance by giving them two attacks but being unable to switch one of them between members to throw trackers / watchers off balance.

[novice]

Three night kills, Lewwyn and Bob both claim not to have killed, and commies only have one kill.

So best case scenario there's one scum faction and a serial killer.

Speaking of which it's mystifying that people are voting to lynch Gazglum when we can just wait and see how Lewwyn flips.

Why does it matter what lewwyn flips?

Serdoa visted lewwyn who didn't move. Unless mattimeo is a roleblocker it's unlikely lewwyn is scum who threw away a night-kill.

Hm, point. Lewwyn is still SK in my mind, I guess I haven't assimilated all the claims info fully.

Catwalk: Asked and answered.

[Serdoa]

I would ask every villager to leave Serdoa and not lynch him. Not today not tomorrow and maybe not on D5.

These were his words. It goes well beyond "let's not lynch him now, I have a hunch he's innocent".

Ichabod, at this point in the game, do you think I am a wolf?

[Catwalk]

As was posted earlier today, it was public knowledge all along that the communists only get one kill per night. And as you point out yourself, the communists can easily have personal kill abilities too. I don't think novice would mess up on a claim like that though, so I'm very interested to hear what he has.

[Catwalk]

Three night kills, Lewwyn and Bob both claim not to have killed, and commies only have one kill.

So best case scenario there's one scum faction and a serial killer.

Speaking of which it's mystifying that people are voting to lynch Gazglum when we can just wait and see how Lewwyn flips.

Was this your evidence? If so, I find it sorely lacking. If not, I'm sorry that I missed it completely and would like it pointed out to me.