WW 31 Game Thread PARANOIA

[MJW (ya that one)]

#3 won't work as you cannot lose more than one clone per night.

[Rowain]

3. Lynch somebody else today. Have Gazglum target Bob. MJW also has the ability to kill and can kill Bob's other clone.

Won't work as only one clone dies/night no matter how many attacks he suffers.

If a player is hit by more than one killing action in one night, they will still only lose one life that night. (Barring role/power shenanigans.)

[Ryan]

@Zak, I think we need to pry into their claims more and see which one is more likley true,BUT if bob is scum. he cant just block my ability or anyone else he thinks has a powerful role to town. Id rather not give a likely sk or scum the power to role block.. I am not taking my vote off him now tbh.

[Ichabod]

I actually think Bob is a wolf, like I've said yesterday, in the post where I correctly identified the wolves. So I'm fine with lynching him even without all this claiming what the heck.

By the way, am I the only vanilla villager around?

[MJW (ya that one)]

@Zak, I think we need to pry into their claims more and see which one is more likley true,BUT if bob is scum. he cant just block my ability or anyone else he thinks has a powerful role to town. Id rather not give a likely sk or scum the power to role block.. I am not taking my vote off him now tbh.

I made bob blow his load by roleblocking himself so this is not a problem.

Are you really roleclaming Ichabod?

[novice]

I am not taking my vote off him now tbh.

As far as I can tell you're not voting anyone.

[zakalwe]

I was about to say the same thing. That's why I asked him what he meant by this:

I am willing to concede on Gagzulm lynch.

Thanks for pointing out the flaw in #3, MJW/Rowain.

[Serdoa]

@Zak, I think we need to pry into their claims more and see which one is more likley true,BUT if bob is scum. he cant just block my ability or anyone else he thinks has a powerful role to town. Id rather not give a likely sk or scum the power to role block.. I am not taking my vote off him now tbh.

Ryan, I don't mean to be mean, but would you care to let us participate how you reached conclusions instead of just posting them? You write that we need to pry into their claims more, but how would we do that? You don't tell. You state that if Bob is scum he can't just block you - I guess you mean he CAN just block you, not can't because then your argument would not make sense. But actually your argument doesn't anyway because he can't block you indeed, not without us knowing at least. And if he did that he would be lynched, worst case scenario we lose your scry for a night. Given that you are not confirmed town and could easily be a scum-roleseer - because your claim that you are just told that they can kill is something I don't believe in the slightest - I don't really think your ability is that important that we couldn't do without it for a night, especially if we get a anti-town-player in exchange.

[Ryan]

A) you dont have to believe it.
B) I was not wrong once.
C) Maybe your worried your my next target tonight?
D) Being able to detect sks and scum is prob a really bad role. Honestly, the people im targeting are the ones that are trying to move the discussion away and not lynch the people who have the ability to kill. If I wanted to get Lewwyn or Bob killed. I would have done much more then just say "they have the ability to kill" and I have played a scum role seer before and I wont that game :D and this isnt my style.
E) I dont mean be mean.
F) Bob is refusing to role claim, Gagzulm is saying that he has to kill every night. You lied about your tracking as MJW said. List goes on. You are honestly seeming more scum to me the way you are redirecting conversation.

[Catwalk]

Serdoa didn't lie about tracking, he was double charged by Qg and went two places that night.