WW 31 Game Thread PARANOIA

[Jowy]

Btw we lost that post, you protected Serdoa and who else was it?

[Ryan]

Why not give me the ability to check two people tonight imo?

[Ichabod]

What is the Ichabod-theorem?

If Ichabods founds playerA scummy and gets the village to follow his lead then playerA is innocent. If Ichabod gets largely ignored and playerA escapes easily then playerA is scum. Of course the theorem only works if Ichabod himself is a villager .

Yeah, that makes sense.

Anyway, I'm fine with lynching any of Bob, Catwalk and Ryan, for basically the reasons already stated in the thread. Sicne these appear to be the most likely targets of the lynch, I'm pretty happy.

[Catwalk]

I mentioned earlier that my ability is called Paranoia. I didn't target anyone last night, since Bob scrubbed me. Sorry for the lack of contribution lately, I'll try to read up tonight or tomorrow. How long until lynch time?

[novice]

I know I'm delving into pure meta here, but I think is the best I can do.

Weren't you vehemently against lynching based on roles yesterday?

[Ryan]

Like how is it logical to gamble a seer vs a vigi... Which one is more usefull imo

[Catwalk]

Lynching vigilantes has given us precious little so far. In a game with this many killers, it makes good sense for scum to have a kill seer. I'm not going to vote you based on just that, but I think it's a decent argument against you. How much time do we have until lynching?

[Mattimeo]

How much time do we have until lynching?

~10 hours + 24 because downtime, I think?

[Ichabod]

I know I'm delving into pure meta here, but I think is the best I can do.

Weren't you vehemently against lynching based on roles yesterday?

Il Ichabod è mobile
Qual piuma al vento,
muta d'accento
e di pensiero.

Yes, I was, but my roughness in expressing it was due to my bad mood (sorry about that), not due to the severity of my conviction.

Anyway, I'm publicly recognizing with my last thoughts that I'm playing a very bad game. I don't feel like spending much time tone reading and looking for contradictions through 2000 posts and that obviously shows in my game. But I still had a bit of fun looking through the claims and trying to find holes in them, using my faulty logic and incomplete info. I hope this is better than nothing, since it's the way I think I can be a little useful (it's either that or act just like Imana-665 - 665 is sort of my "lucky number", by the way -, just picking a good non-suspicious player to piggyback on the lynch votes).

[Qgqqqqq]

Seeing the roles we have, Qg's role seems extremely convoluted. What was it again? And did Qgq follow MJW used it on MJW on night one? I have a feeling that Qgq can be lying about his role, while being the missing watcher. But here's the thing: why would he lie about being the watcher? I mean, we only suspect the watcher role to be a scum-role because no one claimed it, while we know it exists (i.e. someone is lying; lying = scum). I wonder why someone would lie about this...

Exactly, why would I lie when no-one was calling for my reveal, there was no urgency for me to claim, and there were relatively vanilla roles anyway. At some point you asked me to explain again, so it goes like this in my flavor: I can eat flakes of two peoples skin. Because of this I can recognise them for the remainder of the night, and visit a third person to see if either of the previous visited him, and if they did I learn what ability they use. I don't know what a positive result looks like as I've yet to get one. Last night I watched zak to see if space or Ichabod visited him.

I was in a rush at the time so I forgot to use my item.

Ichabod