WW 34--The Slugfest!

[Jabbz]

So Bob went down with 6 votes on him. Seriously great for scum. Lynch the one you can't kill.

Jabbz I seriously wish you had spoken earlier in the day before I went to bed. Maybe we could have actually organized a non-bob lynch. I actually like your posts and think their is some thought there. Frustrating.

Sadly I'm still getting used to my new schedule, so everything is hectic as hell. TBH though, I didn't sway anyone but you apparently, so he would have still swung :/

[BaII]

BaII's only post for the day has been jumping on (what I consider) a bad wagon with effectively the logic of "well, if he's lying it would be really bad, so policy lynch". Not particularly helpful.

Baii will always be a default. Sad but true unless he post more.

Yah sorry about that I was gone all day and only returned home around an hour ago. I still stand by the Bob lynch because I thought with all the power roles in this game that it would have been unlikely that something didn't happen to him by night 1 and triggered his role. I think a further investigation of Jowy might be called for cause I would be interested in his slew of votes at the very end of the day.

[Lewwyn]

This village:

I can't stop watching this.

[Jkaen]

Well, the result was wrong, but I still defend the logic behind it, with the exception i considered this morning when getting up of Novices(?) comment about the bodies being removed tieing in with Q's power, given Bob or anybody else never siezed on it, I didn't give it much thought at the time.

As for the comment above about scum having to push for a village lynch, in my experience as scum you just sit back, maybe nudge gently once a day and let the village kill themselves.

I get the impression I am going to get heat though tomorrow, can I request nobody do any big reveal type post until I get a chance to post first please?

[zakalwe]

You mean this comment, I presume:

"If the person who died got totally destroyed you cannot rob him."

Sunrise's body was charred but not totally destroyed, given that it was found in his house.

So I'd say that supports the existence of some kind of explosive power, like the one Bob has claimed.

I think the best argument in Bob's favor was simply this, though:

I mean that he could have chosen to claim something else, if he's scum.

That's a point I made much earlier in the day. Did you miss that too?

[AdrienIer]

Well Bob had a complicated role, bad luck there, I'd still vote for him in the same situation. I hope the night actions will give us more info

[Jkaen]

You mean this comment, I presume:

"If the person who died got totally destroyed you cannot rob him."

Sunrise's body was charred but not totally destroyed, given that it was found in his house.

So I'd say that supports the existence of some kind of explosive power, like the one Bob has claimed.

I think the best argument in Bob's favor was simply this, though:

I mean that he could have chosen to claim something else, if he's scum.

That's a point I made much earlier in the day. Did you miss that too?

Sorry Zak, yes I did mean your first quote.

The second one I read but didn't put that much weight into. Claiming what he did had the benefit of not being possible to check upon really, any other claim was liable to inspection.

[novice]

Sorry you got such an unfun role, Bob.

But if you are talking about our self appointed lord and master Novice I will entertain the notion.

When did this appointment take place?

[AdrienIer]

Sorry you got such an unfun role, Bob.

But if you are talking about our self appointed lord and master Novice I will entertain the notion.

When did this appointment take place?

I place it at Lewwyn's post 415 were you were basically the guy who'd know all the answers, but there was already some vibes like this before

[Gazglum]

To my eyes, Novice has been both buddying Brick and protecting Jowy.

Out of interest, the brothers' votes so far have been

Day 1

Zak: Qg > Goreripper > Jabbz > Bob

Novice: Goreripper > Goreripper > Qg > Rowain > Bob

Day 2

Zak: Jabbz > Bob > Mattimeo > BaII > Bob

Novice: Bob

Synchronised as usual. It's not a great record, though Jabbz and Goreripper and the lurkers remain to be seen. I don't like Novice's Q vote.

In my experience when these guys are scum they are masters of spending a day hunting busily, then regretfully ending up on their real target at the last minute.

Of course, when they are town they spend the day hunting busily before conscientiously ending up on the target they think best. Still, I think it would be worthwhile for both of them to have a look at the other Day 3, make sure they're not taking advantage of the blind spot.