I think Qgqq just needs to claim his role at this point. The other option seems to be wasting the day by claiming at the last minute.
Jowy, while I agree with some of your early town reads (me, zak, dtay), just dropping one liners will not help us to read you, which I assume is a big part of sharing those reads. In fact, those kind of comments are also an easy way of giving impression of activity. Also, what's your town read on TT?
I'll give a small town lean for Zak for spotting Jabbz's GF comment. That indicates that he's really looking for clues.
Ichabod's posts so far seem genuine. His wolf tell on Qgq was really insightful (Qgqq spending time crafting the post).
Not a huge fan of using maths in WW, but I like dtay's active posting and content so far.
Slight town lean on Molach, his thought process on Azarius seemed to evolve naturally, and didn't feel like a fake attack. I'm not too sure on this, but I think he also prefers playing town over mafia.
Refreshing to see content posts from Matt
. However giving town lean for Zak & Lewwyn based on them playing mafia last game is not solid, since that game was far from a standard mafia game.
Bob, you list reasons in favor of not lynching novice today, but do you still prefer lynching him today? "No one jumping as scummy" comments are unhelpful.
Lewwyn loves playing scum / SK, and I strongly believe he would took them if given the chance. He loves the mind games.
His suspicion of Ichabod is pretty bad IMO (http://realmsbeyond.net/forums/showthrea...#pid518007)
Ichabod's attack on dtay was backtracked to begin with. He included a point regarding his forum personality with comment "maybe it's just how he rolls". So your accusation of him trying to backtrack later doesn't make sense.
Jowy, while I agree with some of your early town reads (me, zak, dtay), just dropping one liners will not help us to read you, which I assume is a big part of sharing those reads. In fact, those kind of comments are also an easy way of giving impression of activity. Also, what's your town read on TT?
I'll give a small town lean for Zak for spotting Jabbz's GF comment. That indicates that he's really looking for clues.
Ichabod's posts so far seem genuine. His wolf tell on Qgq was really insightful (Qgqq spending time crafting the post).
Not a huge fan of using maths in WW, but I like dtay's active posting and content so far.
Slight town lean on Molach, his thought process on Azarius seemed to evolve naturally, and didn't feel like a fake attack. I'm not too sure on this, but I think he also prefers playing town over mafia.
Refreshing to see content posts from Matt
. However giving town lean for Zak & Lewwyn based on them playing mafia last game is not solid, since that game was far from a standard mafia game.Bob, you list reasons in favor of not lynching novice today, but do you still prefer lynching him today? "No one jumping as scummy" comments are unhelpful.
Lewwyn loves playing scum / SK, and I strongly believe he would took them if given the chance. He loves the mind games.
His suspicion of Ichabod is pretty bad IMO (http://realmsbeyond.net/forums/showthrea...#pid518007)
Ichabod's attack on dtay was backtracked to begin with. He included a point regarding his forum personality with comment "maybe it's just how he rolls". So your accusation of him trying to backtrack later doesn't make sense.
(January 28th, 2015, 19:23)Fenn Wrote: Thinking about it, Vanilla Cop can be very powerful in this gametype - unlike regular Cop your potential targets are narrowed down to anybody who didn't discard a vanilla role, against whom a Vanilla result is just as incriminating as Guilty would be (more so even because of possible Godfather). Possibly Mattimeo didn't consider this when he discarded it or his other option was better in his eyes. Not a scum tell but not a town tell either I don't think.Azarius ditched the vanilla cop, not Matt. What do you think of Azarius's explanation on this?
