Are you, in fact, a pregnant lady who lives in the apartment next door to Superdeath's parents? - Commodore

Create an account  

 
WW35: Not Another TPS Report [Game Thread]

Oh, stupid split votes. Never mind... bang
Erebus in the Balance - a FFH Modmod based around balancing and polishing FFH for streamlined competitive play.

Reply

(January 29th, 2015, 20:10)Fenn Wrote: Gazglum, could you explain the bad vibes my posts gave you? Leaving it unspecific isn't helpful, both to the village in finding scum/town and to me as a player. smile

That’s fair enough Fenn, and I am conscious that this is your first day – I was terrified my first day of werewolf here, the moreso because I was innocent and Ichabod kept hounding me (to the point where I went mad and challenged him to a suicidal duel, but that’s a yarn for another day).

But for me and the vibe of your posts, I think Ichabod summed it up well:

(January 29th, 2015, 13:29)Ichabod Wrote: Anyway, he throws a vote against Jabbz on his next post, a person he didn't mention os his suspect post. This gives me the feel (gut feel argument, take it as you like it) that he's disconnected from his previous cases. A villager cares about and nurtures his cases, since they come from his own reasoning; a wolf quickly forgets about his cases, because they were fabricated in the first place.

And I also got a sense that you were kind of dancing among the easy votes: Novice for claiming cop too early, but then you changed your mind. Twinkletoes for pressure. Lewwyn, also for meta, then dropped. Jabbz after he became flavour of the month. I know that pressuring people is also part of the game, and it’s not that scummy in itself. But I would have liked to see more serious analysis of one of those suspects, to make it seem more like a case you were pursuing and less like making noise and moving on.

Being a good wolf is all about being seen without being noticed, so posts that ‘add to the discussion’ without driving it anywhere are good wolfy posts. And my feeling is that a few of yours have been in that vein, either the ‘lets look at the facts’ posts:

(January 28th, 2015, 13:32)Fenn Wrote: You could make the case for taking Vanilla Townie over Miller or Lover, those roles are just liabilities for the person playing them.
But yeah, all that discarding Vanilla Townie/Miller means is that the person's other role was more interesting - that's not much to answer for.

Or friendly conversational stuff, which is nice, but also can be a warning sign if its not backed up with more analysis posts.

(January 29th, 2015, 21:52)Fenn Wrote: It seems Qgqqqqq has the perfect strategy to avoid getting lynched! lol

Anyway, I’m not going to vote for you today, because there are plenty of better choices. But (if you are town) I hope that helps a bit with explaining what Ichabod or I or others would see as warning signs.
Reply

Actually I won't have time for a reread, everyone disagrees with me on Zak, I'll put my vote on Lewwyn [/color][color=#000000]for now
Reply

I think the timing of your claim is good nevertheless, seeing the amount of votes you've received through the game. We would have spent the next day on the same topic if you'd survive the night. Towns who have suspected you can look elsewhere for now.

I'm still strongly in favor of lynching Lewwyn today.

Ichabod, who specifically you didn't like on Qgq voters?
Reply

DRAMA!

[Image: images?q=tbn:ANd9GcQ1OT6ANw5A1tFscG1YiTN...n4-nr_yNjv]

Two cops. Two organisations. How do you know where evil lies?

I think Q has been playing a pretty good game lately, so if we get into a cop-off I would pick Novice to hang. But I think leave them both alive for now?
Reply

Good. I believe your claim. Q, there were many who had only hopped off momentarily, you did the right thing.
Now we can lynch someone else, and you're actually safer at night. You might get protection or a watcher on you. Scum will have to take risks if they want to remove you. Also no chance of being shot by a vigilante anymore.

I think I'd like to lynch Lewwyn or Novice today. Jabbz is also highly suspicious but I'm less confident on him because this could potentially be his first town game.
Reply

I don't think lynching novice is a right move either, since we can have two town cops.
Reply

Agreeing with Meiz here, I don't see how lynching novice is better than lynching Q right now
Reply

(January 30th, 2015, 07:08)Jowy Wrote: Good. I believe your claim. Q, there were many who had only hopped off momentarily, you did the right thing.
Now we can lynch someone else, and you're actually safer at night. You might get protection or a watcher on you. Scum will have to take risks if they want to remove you. Also no chance of being shot by a vigilante anymore.

I think I'd like to lynch Lewwyn or Novice today. Jabbz is also highly suspicious but I'm less confident on him because this could potentially be his first town game.

Agree with Lewwyn. He threw away innocent child for a more fun role (which for him would include scum), voted for Q for throwing away roleblocker on a more fun role, jabbed at Ichabod then withdrew, then after being pressured by Meiz and Zak vanished completely.
Reply

(January 30th, 2015, 07:10)Meiz Wrote: I don't think lynching novice is a right move either, since we can have two town cops.

What makes you think novice is town?
Reply



Forum Jump: