WW35: Not Another TPS Report [Game Thread]

[Twinkletoes89]

Jabbz, and for the rest of the group...

Molach explained it perfectly (more than once)

I said it earlier.
If village has tracker you need the killer to not be followed.
If village has watcher you need target to not be watched.
...this is a difference, they are free to choose killer and target so they have less freedom without claim.

[Meiz]

In any case, I think pushing TT is towny paranoia. My strongest town reads are Zak, Jowy, Jabbz & Fenn.

So the people without claimed roles really need to pick it up, Molach, Jkaen & Azarius. If you are town, you are a mislynch waiting to happen. Please give concrete reads on your view of the game. Just stating someone is shady doesn't cut it.

[Jabbz]

I am the town doctor. On night one I protected Mattimeo. I verified with BRIck that I block EVERY attempt on a person’s life when I target them. His death anyway is most likely attributed to a Strongman, unless Bob jailed me. While it is possible the Sycophants blocked me, I don’t believe I did anything on day one that would make me a threat to them, quite the opposite as I was a pretty good lynch target as the night ended.

Yesterday I protected Qg. Given there were three deaths last night, I find it unlikely that I blocked one, but it is not impossible.

I find it highly suspicious that Qg was not killed last night, as he is the remaining claimed cop. There may be additional information here that I am not aware of, but it bothers me.

I have little to no read on Meiz. I know that I tend to suffer from tunnel vision in these games, something I’m working on.

Jowy has seemed to be very sketchy a lot of this game. He makes assertions and operates under the assumption that we can’t help but agree with him. This somewhat falls in line with other games I’ve seen him in however, so I don’t know if this is a huge tell or not.

Azarius is way too quiet for me this game. Part of it could be because of his current issues, but I’m disinclined to give him too much credit for that. He has made a few good contributions, but overall I feel his content is pretty light. His role doesn’t tell us much I believe, as it’s a relatively useless role with this many power role options in the game.

Zakalwe seems scummy as hell to me. I am having a hard time pinning that down to a specific statement, which is why I haven’t posted anything yet on him. Unfortunately his role was pretty terrible from the way I read it, so his dropping that provides us with very little information.

Molach also seems sketchy to me. Unfortunately it is in a similar vein to Zakalwe, it’s hard for me to pin anything down, so I don’t have much to say about it.

Jkaen I get slight town reads from, if for no other reason than the fact that, unlike almost every other player alive, he hasn’t done anything to look scummy lately.

TT. I bought you as a possible sk/mafia before you refused to claim, when claiming did nothing. Now I’m pretty much sold on the idea.

Ich, I hate you. You were in my circle of trust. You are now outside of it. I am crying as I type this.

Fenn I have no readings on one way or the other.

The main reason I am willing to out myself is that I feel that my role contributes very little to the rest of the game. The mafia has a strongman, until/unless we kill him, I am useless. Yes I could have hid and hoped that we would get the strongman, but this forces the town’s hand, and I think that a mass claim is beneficial. I could have waited till later in the day, so others could claim my role and I could out them, but I believe that, absent pushing for this claim, I lack enough town cred to make it clear that I am town they are lying. Sure I would have confirmed, but I would likely end up a miss lynch in the process. Further, this would just keep pushing back a role claim until it was too late to have solid analysis of people’s claims. Enough people are pushing for us to wait “just one more night” which I believe would continue until the scum won.
That being said, lets kick this shit in gear.

[Jkaen]

Ahh this makes sense. If we assume that there are 2 active sk's and that an attempt on q was blocked last night I think reading the reaction today shows who the second SK is. I would like people to read without my bias but if you want I will state outright who I think it is

[Jkaen]

Ahh forget being mysterious. The other SK I think is fenn

[Meiz]

How so?

[Jkaen]

Look at his posts he seems very worried about giving sk's a chance while not really buying into the TT is a SK argument. On phone in bed so can't lonk the posts now

[zakalwe]

Seems more logical to suspect Q. Strongman kill on Mattimeo goes through, strongman kill on Q fails, because he is the mafia-immune SK.

[zakalwe]

If so, Q killed Rowain, AdrienIer killed Bob, and Ichabod killed AdrienIer.

Hey Ichabod... we have a job for you. :D

[Jabbz]

I don't think there was a kill attempt on Q last night. There was a good reason for not going after a "confirmed" cop on night one. Mattimeo had much more town cred, was playing it closer to the vest, and Qg was under a reasonable amount of suspicion throughout the day. Night two, those reasons disappear, yet no one tries to kill Qg.