WW35: Not Another TPS Report [Game Thread]

[Fenn]

Oh right TT could still be a SK that whiffed his shot on you. Makes sense I guess.

[Jowy]

I think the split is 8-2-1 atm. We lynch the SK and mafia kills one of us, tomorrow it's 7-2. We can afford two miss-lynches. All 4 players who discarded scum were town, so I highly doubt that mafia has more than 2 players alive right now.

Mafia's best chance is to keep Ichabod alive to kill townies. Which makes Zak's vote very interesting indeed

[Twinkletoes89]

Oh for the love of god, just kill Ichabod and be done with it.

You are taking a 100% shot in the dark on Azarius with only the fact that he has been super quiet to condemn him. He mentioned (I believe) a rather pressing personal issue of his uncle's (?) house being burgled as something that may take up his time.

Please, please, do not take a crapshoot over a sure thing.

Ichabod can promise the world, he has nothing left to lose. But what happens next? We have to lynch him at some point to win as he can't die at night. Azarius may well be able to die at night or we can lynch him on the next day.

You are giving him the opportunity to shoot people and a ready made excuse of a possible second SK to cover his tracks.

[Fenn]

I confess, I just hate to lynch Ichabod after his impassioned defence today. But if that's what everyone else want to do then that's fine, it is the best option for town objectively.

[Molach]

... I honestly don't have much of a clue where the others are right now.

I am here, watching, just not posting. I would have posted some %¤% but seems everything worked out great without that.

Jabbz claim even meant Jowy could azarius. Talk about...good play.

If we had 2 mafia known, we could lynch one of them and instruct Ichabod to kill the other, but as it is lynch should be obvious. If we lynch Azarius who gets to be SK-Killed tonight?

Would we gain anything by day-vigging Azarius now? If anyone has the skill?

[Qgqqqqq]

Twinkletoes, why are you defending Azarius so badly? Why are you saying he's done nothing but be quiet when we have a incriminating result from Jowy on him? (I checked, and Jowy's right that there's no village role that Azarius could be - supposing you're town, that is.)

I mean, I agree that Ichabod is the better lynch. I just don't see why you'd be so eager to defend Azarius.

[Qgqqqqq]

Honestly, if I could I would day-vig Ichabod. Like I said, we gain nothing from keeping him alive, and he's a definite lynch at some stage.

But that's just me. The other strategy, of course, is to save it up as long as possible to get a better chance of hitting scum.

[Twinkletoes89]

Twinkletoes, why are you defending Azarius so badly? Why are you saying he's done nothing but be quiet when we have a incriminating result from Jowy on him? (I checked, and Jowy's right that there's no village role that Azarius could be - supposing you're town, that is.)

I mean, I agree that Ichabod is the better lynch. I just don't see why you'd be so eager to defend Azarius.

Calm down the rhetoric Q.

Everyone starts voting for Azarius, I made a valid point as to why its a stupid idea right now (which you agree with) and also reminded people of a possible valid reason for why he may be genuinely afk without it being an indication of guilt.

If talking sense to stupid is being 'eager to defend' someone, then fine.

Plus, Mr Useless Cop, given that you are the only investigative player left alive (supposedly) why do you not account for the point that other claim makers may have lied?

Additionally, if there is no villager role that Azarius could be, then why aren't you voting for the others who have made no claim at all (like Zak). If that 'evidence' is enough to damn Azarius, then it damns them too.

[Twinkletoes89]

Additionally, if there is no villager role that Azarius could be, then why aren't you voting for the others who have made no claim at all (like Zak). If that 'evidence' is enough to damn Azarius, then it damns them too.

To further expound on this. If this is your evidence to condemn him, then why not go after the louder ones first that this evidence also condemns? Azarius may be scum, but he's effectively silent and not dropping misinformation to muddy the waters.

[Jowy]

let's not day vig the bulletproof guy.

good night all.