On Jkaen's early day 2:
His post early on of 'if you feel the need to lynch me to clear way from proper discussion' feels off - when you put it like that at the start of day 2 of course people will not lynch you right away. Like he's saying it to gain town cred, not because he means it. He makes big case posts against Bob, dtay and TT, voting against Bob. Notable that when Jkaen voted for Bob at a point when votes were 4/4/3 for dtay/Bob/TT, but that's not strong evidence for being mafia. Him continuing to push his Jowy case into Day 2 I don't like either. Don't know if Jkaen as scum would push a hopeless case, but it looks scummy to me now.
Honestly though zakalwe's Day 2 play is fishier now that I look back at it. He calls out Bob repeatedly for his factual error in his TT case (claiming that TT pushed claimed cop Q, but TT didn't post pushing him after Q had claimed), then (post #692) more agreeing with Gaz and Adrien's cases on Bob. Actually half his serious posts at this time are about Bob. No smoking gun here, and I suppose it's good that zak is consistent in his suspicion of Bob, but it doesn't read well to me imo. His posting in the rest of the game has been good overall, so possibly he just made a mistake wrt Bob.
My thoughts about a possible Q/TT scumteam: Q as scum could be bussing TT to exonerate himself for endgame. Right now we've got a setup where both claim that the other is lying about their night actions, especially N1, which would suggest that if one flips mafia the other is town. Notice TT at the start of the day bringing up the 'mythical roleblocker' business again. If TT flips as a Mafia Roleblocker this would add support to Q's explanation of not dying previously too - Mafia was sure they could roleblock him while killing more important players.
Of course this could also mean that mafia is deliberately leaving Qg alive to make him look suspicious. I kind of doubt that Q and TT are actually mafia together, but it wouldn't be out of the question.
His post early on of 'if you feel the need to lynch me to clear way from proper discussion' feels off - when you put it like that at the start of day 2 of course people will not lynch you right away. Like he's saying it to gain town cred, not because he means it. He makes big case posts against Bob, dtay and TT, voting against Bob. Notable that when Jkaen voted for Bob at a point when votes were 4/4/3 for dtay/Bob/TT, but that's not strong evidence for being mafia. Him continuing to push his Jowy case into Day 2 I don't like either. Don't know if Jkaen as scum would push a hopeless case, but it looks scummy to me now.
Honestly though zakalwe's Day 2 play is fishier now that I look back at it. He calls out Bob repeatedly for his factual error in his TT case (claiming that TT pushed claimed cop Q, but TT didn't post pushing him after Q had claimed), then (post #692) more agreeing with Gaz and Adrien's cases on Bob. Actually half his serious posts at this time are about Bob. No smoking gun here, and I suppose it's good that zak is consistent in his suspicion of Bob, but it doesn't read well to me imo. His posting in the rest of the game has been good overall, so possibly he just made a mistake wrt Bob.
My thoughts about a possible Q/TT scumteam: Q as scum could be bussing TT to exonerate himself for endgame. Right now we've got a setup where both claim that the other is lying about their night actions, especially N1, which would suggest that if one flips mafia the other is town. Notice TT at the start of the day bringing up the 'mythical roleblocker' business again. If TT flips as a Mafia Roleblocker this would add support to Q's explanation of not dying previously too - Mafia was sure they could roleblock him while killing more important players.
Of course this could also mean that mafia is deliberately leaving Qg alive to make him look suspicious. I kind of doubt that Q and TT are actually mafia together, but it wouldn't be out of the question.
".
Totally! Every time...
