WW35: Not Another TPS Report [Game Thread]

[zakalwe]

Brick, rules question. If a strongman is jailed by a jailkeeper, can he still make a successful kill?

[Jabbz]

See I still find this hugely suspicious. What exactly are you willing to defend against?

Not responding to any random accusations seems very odd to me. Am I allowed to say I will only comment to people who are supporting me being obvious town?

I have three responses to this Jkaen.

First, is that I have fielded over a dozen attacks on me to date, all successfully.
Second is that I have actually claimed my role, and did it under no pressure, when I could have been outed for claiming something I didn't actually have.
Third is that I have been extremely accurate and agressive to date with my hunting of scum.

Those three should give me enough town cred to not have to let the conversation get redirected to me constantly, as scum doesn't want me hunting and instead wants to try to bring up bs claims against me.

That's my perception of why I should be able to get away with it anyway.

[zakalwe]

Zakalwe should be considered as confirmed towAAAARRGHHHHHHHHHHHH

Also, can we get this as the QotM, please.

[Fenn]

That's...a turnaround and a half from Fenn, there. Like, suspiciously so, especially the definitive statement despite nothing there having changed from earlier - and I don't recall you seizing on, or being wary of, any of those bits previously. This looks a lot like a scum seeing another railroad lynch and being eager to set it on its tracks.

I explained why I asked to be jailed an eon and a half ago, btw. And since when was Mattimeo "obviously going to be killed"? That's a very retroactive statement, Imo. Certainly he was the most obvious town of the lot, but without a strongarm there was a very good chance he'd survive the night. Not to mention the fact that when I made my claim we had novicce/I as cops, with no idea that Mattimeo was also around.

I know you explained why you wanted to be jailed a while ago. Your explanation is scummy and I regret I didn't pick up on it before now.

You knew Mattimeo would die because you're on the Mafia team, you knew you had a Strongman and your best move was to kill Mattimeo the confirmed cop. Of course it would have been preferable if nobody else claimed cop on Day 1, but it was pretty likely in the scenario where you and novice are lying. Once Matt claimed he had to die.

Qgqqqqq

Jkaen, what do you think about having the remaining players claim? Probably won't help too much, but with all the town power roles dead or claimed it could be worth a shot...

[Jkaen]

Jabbz, at this point in the game everybody gets suspicion thrown at them even golden boy zak

[Jkaen]

Jkaen, what do you think about having the remaining players claim? Probably won't help too much, but with all the town power roles dead or claimed it could be worth a shot...

I think every single player unclaimed can safely claim vanilla townie, hence it won't achieve anything. We wouldn't catch anybody with it, and it may throw up hidden roles still worth hiding.

If the town wants to do it sure, but i can't see what its going to do.

[Fenn]

True, there are some town roles left still worth keeping hidden. Now that I think about the ones remaining are most useful if they're a surprise so yeah, probably not worth it.

[Jabbz]

Name one of the remaining players that has as much as me to show they are town, yet is still getting constantly sniped by qg and zak? They are targeting me because I am effective. So again, if someone has a legit, wow I think jabbz is scum because statement to make, I'll defend against it.

Anyway, homework. BBL.

[BRickAstley]

Brick, rules question. If a strongman is jailed by a jailkeeper, can he still make a successful kill?

Yes he can.

[Qgqqqqq]

@Fenn: Why didn't you pick up on it till now? Did you reread all the posts? Just mine? What led to your massive change of heart?