WW 36 - Horrors in Kingsport [Game Thread]

[Fenn]

My feelings about this day so far, in summary:

[Qgqqqqq]

(ooc: Q, if I hurt your enjoyment of last game then I apologize; I only considered my Vengeful gambit my best shot at helping the town catch the last scum.)

Don't be silly - enjoyed it to the last.


Not sure where you got vehemence from...I think you're attributing a touch too much emotion to my posts.

Then zak voted with for with no explanation and that + a general bad feeling I had had about his style that day was enough to make me jump off of the Matt train. Indeed I'd been after you most of the day, but I wasn't feeling strongly about your scumminess then (and I still don't), so I was willing to vote with you at least temporarily.

...I'm pretty sure you voted Zak before he voted matt with no explanation

[Gazglum]

Qgqqq red vote, cant get phone to work.
Too early for self pitying 'when I flip town' post.

Will xontribute properly tomorrow.[/color]

[AdrienIer]

It's not too unlikely that the horrors slew zakalwe because he suspected Q, but wasn't as vocal about it as he was his BRick case. Yeah wifom, but scum don't pick their targets out of a hat. Scum!Q would have good reason to want zakalwe out of his hair.

What are you even...

If I'm scum, then killing Zak to get him out of my hair is not a good tactic. Zak was the alternative lynch, and nowhere near so towny as to be impossible to scumcast on. Thus, killing him loses a defense for scum me (as well as others who pushed Zak, btw) - that he and matt were both scum - and strengthens the case against Zak votes, increasing their prominence today.

Thus, scum me wanting to kill him to further my own defense is simply inane.

(Which is not to say that scum me wouldn't do it - he was quite towny, and he's zakalwe so he's already a strong candidate absent roles. It's perfectly possible that my scum faction decided to take this chance despite the harm it would do to my defense, but it's certainly no motivation for scum wanti my to protect me.)

Saul caught a lot of heat Day 1 and chose not to push Mattimeo (who imo was scummy for the content of his posts in addition to lurking), but two townies in zak and myself. Suppose he could have just chosen poorly - I wasn't exactly obvtown- or didn't want to lynch Mattimeo for meta reasons, but it's still scummy to me on balance. Regardless I prefer the case on Qgqqqqq that novice and Brick have put forward today and last night. His actions look more suspicious in light of zak's town flip.

...oh whatever.


Still, when I flip today, look back on AdrienIers opportunism here. He's keeping his options open with a nice suspicion floating around on Saul, and his jumping on the night kill to scumfirm me just reeks. Actually makes me less suspicious of everyone else on Zak, though I don't doubt there's someone lurking amongst them (probably Fenn, but maybe I'm still angry about last game).

I thought that was Adrien I was quoting.

So you're suspecting Fenn right ?

[Qgqqqqq]

Right.

I didn't say when I flipped town. But whatever.

[AdrienIer]

Still, when I flip today, look back on AdrienIers opportunism here. He's keeping his options open with a nice suspicion floating around on Saul, and his jumping on the night kill to scumfirm me just reeks. Actually makes me less suspicious of everyone else on Zak, though I don't doubt there's someone lurking amongst them (probably Fenn, but maybe I'm still angry about last game).

You did though

[AdrienIer]

Unless you mean when you flip scum ?

[Qgqqqqq]

Exactly.


(Well, what I mean is there's a subtle difference. Saying when I flip town is a touch pretentious, like pushing it in peoples faces that you are town, and is something that is IMO slightly scummy - because scum are always eager to ram that home, because they're more defensive about the whole thing. Same thing when people make lists and include themselves as town, for example.)

[AdrienIer]

Ok it makes sense

[BRickAstley]

Q how is that not you basically you saying you're going to flip town? "when I flip" unless you're declaring your guilt is pretty much. You say there's a subtle difference but the only difference is that you're implying rather than implicitly stating it.

An aside, I feel a little wary that this day has been really quiet so far.