I doubt you're going to swing Qg. I don't see enough of a reason to vote for you, and anyone else switching like this would be fishy as hell.
As to Fenn, the best argument I'm seeing is:
From AdrienIer
(February 22nd, 2015, 13:17)AdrienIer Wrote: I'm going to change my vote to Fenn for now, I started my reread on him and I don't like what I see. Several weird things like
(February 20th, 2015, 17:05)Fenn Wrote: Doctor Saul caught a lot of heat Day 1 and chose not to push Mattimeo (who imo was scummy for the content of his posts in addition to lurking), but two townies in zak and myself.
I think he stated things like "well I'm town so..." two or three times. Worth noting IMO
But it's not my main argument (I know I've said similar things myself before), more importantly his posts lacked any sort of real content until 10 pages ago, when he was attacked, and still the posts aren't long. He's been clearly lurking at several moments, summarizing the state of the game to Lewwyn at the end of D1 for example, yet not doing real scumhunting.
Another quote I have a problem with is this :
(February 21st, 2015, 03:34)Fenn Wrote: Decisiveness is not something I have in spades for better or worse.
Last game your decisiveness almost won the game for town. Shooting Q was dangerous yet you went with it without flinching.
Taking a shower and grabbing something to eat before reading about the other contenders.
It's not really a gotcha, just a that's kind of strange. It's not however, enough for my to decide to lynch him.
As to voting Fenn, which someone said I would likely do in order to survive, I'm not going to.
Someone else pointed out that town doesn't have to survive to win. Just make good arguments that survive their death. My time this game day has been short, so I haven't left as much behind me as I'd like, but it will have to do. I don't think there is enough of a case on Fenn to lynch him. I also don't think there is enough on Qg, though in that case it wouldn't matter, as I would still be top lynch target.
If I vote for fenn, and he pops town, then the entire discussion tomorrow is going to be about me, and how I'm scum, and that wastes a town day. So I'm going to put my vote on the guy that I think is most likely to be scum, and that's dtay. I don't buy that he is as inept as he is acting. His mischaracterizations of my arguments is suspicious as hell, and I think it's a wolf's attempt to use his newbness to throw out a lot of non-information that clouds the water. After I lynch, make sure you go back and check his big posts, because I'm sure you are going to find the same kind of crap there that existed in his character assassination on me.
@ Jabbz Things I didn't like on Fenn the parroting of Lewwyn on D1, the jumping on zak , the agreeing with me about the zak-kill.
It is not a strong case and the vote was partly done to have 3 candidates up else nobody else was pushed. BRick didn't get pushed, dtay neither. Gaspar and Lewwyn attracted no followers and even novice did only earn 2 prodding votes an nothing serious.
It is interesting for me to note that the good Dr who at least tried to get Fenn lynched yesterday is not voting him today.
(February 22nd, 2015, 14:29)Qgqqqqq Wrote: I'm something called "knower of boots" or something similar. Basically I see if anyone save myself has visited a player that night, though I don't learn their identities. It might involve the previous night as well, I need to check that, but irrelevant night 1. I checked Saul because I thought he might be visited by a village pr and I'd be good to confirm. No one visited him save me.
Interesting, Mattimeo was a Knower of Own Boots. You're saying that you're that same role?
(February 22nd, 2015, 14:29)Qgqqqqq Wrote: I'm something called "knower of boots" or something similar. Basically I see if anyone save myself has visited a player that night, though I don't learn their identities. It might involve the previous night as well, I need to check that, but irrelevant night 1. I checked Saul because I thought he might be visited by a village pr and I'd be good to confirm. No one visited him save me.
Ok, thanks Rowain, that supports my feel that the case against him is mostly weak, which isn't too surprising for day 2 I suppose. As to the Dr, yeah I noted that too. The only reason I placed my vote on dtay, is because I feel he is under less suspicion than the Dr. is, and I want my death to put more emphasis on him.
(February 22nd, 2015, 14:27)Fenn Wrote: Novice sounds good on day 2, reads like he's trying to hunt scum which is good. Maybe I'm biased because he hasn't focused on me though.
Novice sounds scummy to me today. Not sure you can say novice trying to hunt scum when he's been on Qg all day.
Huh I remembered him doing more than that day 2. Looks like you're right actually, can't find much else from him on a day 2 skim.
(February 22nd, 2015, 14:25)Qgqqqqq Wrote: Oh and btw Jabbz feels village. His frustration is OTT IMO, but that doesn't surprise me from last game and the feel is similar.
This is what my gut is telling me, and why I didn't place the vote until recently. It's good to see him posting now. Part of my suspciion on him was that after saying he was all against me he switched to mattimeo, and didn't say a peep against me today. Well, until just now.
