|
As a French person I feel like it's my duty to explain strikes to you. - AdrienIer |
|
WW 36 - Horrors in Kingsport [Game Thread]
|
(February 24th, 2015, 17:04)novice Wrote:(February 24th, 2015, 16:59)AdrienIer Wrote: First meaningful Gaspar post : main thing I'm keeping is the attack on Sunrise which feels real. I don't see them as being scumbuddies, complicated scum plot isn't to be ruled out completely but in this case I doubt it. It goes on for a few posts. I mean at most 1 of them is scum
Tally as of post 753:
6 votes: Qgqqqqq (Lewwyn, BRickAstley, novice, Gaspar, Doctor Saul, Jabbz) 1 votes: novice (Qgqqqqq) 1 votes: Saul (Gazglum) Voting history: So um... yeah this day has turned pretty one sided. Quiet like yesterday, but on one person instead of undecided on a few. It's giving me a bit of cold feet, cause it could either be us catching a scum well like mattimeo and scum bussing onwards, or we've got a villager scum are happy to mislynch. I still feel pretty confident in Q based on what he's said though. It just makes for another quiet day. Lacking a bit of direction, anyone have another person specifically that needs analyzed I can look more heavily at? 
AdrienIer, i like uour posts a lot more today, that's some good digging into cases there. I can agree with you on sunrise, he's been skating along for quite a while so far and it's day 3 soo......
(February 24th, 2015, 17:01)AdrienIer Wrote: This is quite depressing... I'm longing for a moment of "of course, it was him all along" like last game with Bob. Of course I was wrong then but it gave me a purpose.  Most of the time it feels like my most sure cases are all flops too.
Few quick hits then I want to do a couple rereads, even if I suck at them usually.
The post Lewwyn highlighted of Qg gave me the same reaction when I read it, like he was just parroting. Those are one of my favorite scumtells - lazy and/or contrived arguments. I get the hypocrisy, since I'm a very spur of the moment player myself. But while this wasn't quite the Azarius post in my last game (I was right btw, even if you idiots lynched me) those types of scumtells are the best for me... ...that said, there is no way that all of novice, Lewwyn and Saul are town and there's no way that scum are bussing a player on D3 after losing one on D1. Deep cover aside, that's somewhere between 40 and 67 percent of their team going down early - you'd have to be really suicidal for that. And Qg's claim makes no sense as scum - they'd almost certainly come up with something unique in the scum thread for him to throw out. So I'm of two minds. Especially since I have a fairly heavily town read on Saul at the moment and neither novice nor Lewwyn will ever give me a gotcha moment. I think there's at least one, but probably only one scum in the novice, Lewwyn, Saul bucket. Beyond that, I can see any of dtay, Jabbz and sunrise as scum. And I have pretty much no read on Brick at all. The others are at least lean town for me. I'll keep my vote on Qg for now but am going to reread the potential Alpha Scum.
I've got some dirt on my shoulder, can you brush it off for me?
(February 24th, 2015, 18:30)Gaspar Wrote: I think there's at least one, but probably only one scum in the novice, Lewwyn, Saul bucket. Reminds me, part of the feeling for my uneasiness is both Lewwyn and Novice who I felt particularly unsure about early in the day are also with me early on Q. Has to be some shenanigans by someone somewhere surely...
You know Gaspar, Q's claim could simply be the truth.
I understand people's uneasiness with the sudden consensus but what can you do. If Sunrise tries to lurk through the entire day I'm all for lynching him instead. Well, as long as Q delurks, at least. Policy lynches ftw.
I have to run.
(February 24th, 2015, 18:56)novice Wrote: You know Gaspar, Q's claim could simply be the truth. It could be, yes. But if it were me, I'd be reticent to claim it even if it were true for just that reason. Why not just lie about it, nobody finds out until you're dead anyway? Anyway, this is all WIFOM I guess.
I've got some dirt on my shoulder, can you brush it off for me?
|
