[quote=adrien]
Not much to respond to that because yes technically there's no argument against a BRick+me pair. We've hardly ever interacted all game. All I can say is that the story from BRick's perspective makes sense, while the story against him involves a complicated plot that no one can really explain. Two or three people said they put me in their super town column, and BRick was pondering on the Lewwyn vs Novice case when he made his choice so couldn't use Lewwyn as his third guy.
You've been saying that BRick seems town for hours now. You can't just give arguments against me, then arguments in favor of BRick, and then give another argument against me that involve BRick being scum. You have to chose your side, but if BRick is town then this argument is moot. If BRick is scum then... lynch him maybe ? And then don't count me as town on the last day ? If this was the situation you'd be better off having no-experience me against you on the last day rather than Machiavellian BRick who's just pulled a super trick on you.
[/adrien]
Clarifying here because I think there's misunderstanding. That post (as I think I noted in the post itself when I said this should have gone udner the brick stuff) is a lot more about brick than it is about you.
The fact that you/brick makes sense as a scum pair is a ton more consequential for Brick's scumminess than yours. The critical problem with brick being scum is "why fake the scan", which you being scum would at least partially resolve. The you/brick combo is only minorly an argument against you, in so far as it increases the number of background scenerios in which scum you makes sense.
As far as optimal ordering if I'm trying to catch this scum pair, it definatley makes more sense to me to lynch you first, since you flipping town is a lot of town points for Brick, while you flipping scum is a lot of scum points. Versus brick flipping tells me not a ton about you.
Need to churn out a paper until 2 hours before deadine, will probably by able to answer a question or two before then but can't do a large post or respond to a lot of things until then.
Not much to respond to that because yes technically there's no argument against a BRick+me pair. We've hardly ever interacted all game. All I can say is that the story from BRick's perspective makes sense, while the story against him involves a complicated plot that no one can really explain. Two or three people said they put me in their super town column, and BRick was pondering on the Lewwyn vs Novice case when he made his choice so couldn't use Lewwyn as his third guy.
You've been saying that BRick seems town for hours now. You can't just give arguments against me, then arguments in favor of BRick, and then give another argument against me that involve BRick being scum. You have to chose your side, but if BRick is town then this argument is moot. If BRick is scum then... lynch him maybe ? And then don't count me as town on the last day ? If this was the situation you'd be better off having no-experience me against you on the last day rather than Machiavellian BRick who's just pulled a super trick on you.
[/adrien]
Clarifying here because I think there's misunderstanding. That post (as I think I noted in the post itself when I said this should have gone udner the brick stuff) is a lot more about brick than it is about you.
The fact that you/brick makes sense as a scum pair is a ton more consequential for Brick's scumminess than yours. The critical problem with brick being scum is "why fake the scan", which you being scum would at least partially resolve. The you/brick combo is only minorly an argument against you, in so far as it increases the number of background scenerios in which scum you makes sense.
As far as optimal ordering if I'm trying to catch this scum pair, it definatley makes more sense to me to lynch you first, since you flipping town is a lot of town points for Brick, while you flipping scum is a lot of scum points. Versus brick flipping tells me not a ton about you.
Need to churn out a paper until 2 hours before deadine, will probably by able to answer a question or two before then but can't do a large post or respond to a lot of things until then.
Fear cuts deeper than swords.
