WW 36 - Horrors in Kingsport [Game Thread]

[sunrise089]

I also think the first one is true. I think Brick and AdrienIer are both scum, and the plan was to go something like this: In day 3, when the Q was on the block and novice and other people were pushing the case, Brick got the idea to push through the Q lynch and then claim he used his power on 3 people. One would be Gaspar, who the scum team night kills. The second would be novice, who he had been building suspicion on throughout day 3, up to the novice vote after Q's reveal. The third would be innocent AdrienIer, who most of the town had accepted. Brick says that he likes AdrienIer's posting more in day 3, but I can't say I see AdrienIer really doing much more upon looking at it again. He asks a lot of questions and does a lot of nothing.

When I wrote Gaspar in this paragraph I meant to say Gazglum.

Lol, was so confused

[AdrienIer]

I noticed that Saul's role is counter-intuitive in the sense that he gets "positive" results if the target is innocent and "negative" if he's guilty (simplifying here). Normally the question you want to ask the GM is "is he the wolf". BRick do you mind re-reading your role MP and night result MP to make sure you didn't make the stupidest mistake ever ? And Sunrise can you confirm that your role hasn't tempered with BRick's ? It can wait till morning if you don't want the wolves to know about it yet.

[AdrienIer]

I'm rereading everything (yes I'll reread all 123 pages) keeping in mind that BRick Gaspar and Matt are a scum team. I just laughed very hard when on post 65 Rowain mentions BRick/myself scum pair.

About Brick are you suggesting that we're both scum and he went to my rescue halfway through D1 when I have 3 votes ? That would be

the worst scum play ever
Brick's "defensive" post was I think just an attempt at humor in an apparently too serious ww community

BRick has used "A scum would never do that" with great success when he claimed a clear anti-town-power and managed to get 3 night-kill-immune villagers lynched by town before.
But maybe you are town - scum defending townies has happened before and is usual a very nice play for scum. They get a townfriend that way and defending a townie is far easier for scum than attacking because they know who is innocent or not.

In short I currently find BRick more scummy than you (or any other).

I do feel like the townfriend part was true though...

[BRickAstley]

I think Brick and AdrienIer are both scum

This is Pindisaul:

[BRickAstley]

I noticed that Saul's role is counter-intuitive in the sense that he gets "positive" results if the target is innocent and "negative" if he's guilty (simplifying here). Normally the question you want to ask the GM is "is he the wolf". BRick do you mind re-reading your role MP and night result MP to make sure you didn't make the stupidest mistake ever ? And Sunrise can you confirm that your role hasn't tempered with BRick's ? It can wait till morning if you don't want the wolves to know about it yet.

Nope, I've been reading my role correctly. You're still scum.

[BRickAstley]

This day one is going to be super random. At least at the start. So I might as well use random.org for the first vote. I am therefore voting for number 10 [/color]:
AdrienIer

Oh...

Second try is better :
Mattimeo

You know this is reeeeeeeeally interesting in retrospect.

[AdrienIer]

Because your D1 was better ? I just finished reading it and you started the Zak wagon with Saul, before dialing back when you realized how scummy it looked

[AdrienIer]

And you were the one who started attacking Q on real matters (not for attacking me), which made him a target for the next days. All on day 1...

[AdrienIer]

I told you that switch to Zak looked fishy. Ok, it was actually Matt that looked fishy, but you know what I mean.

On the plus side I'd expect a wolf to be in that push

GG Matt

Well, that ended up better than expected. I'm still not sure if village Matt would have played that different than wolf Matt. But we have a wolf dead, and a very interesting end of the day switch to analyze.

All the members of the push are dead except Saul and you. I agree with the Saul post. Well I don't need convincing now, if you didn't misread your role then you're scum. Do people really think that 3 scum would be on Matt on D1 ? Actively making sure he was killed ?

[AdrienIer]

Zak spent a lot of N1 talking about how he's going to go after BRick on D2. At the end of the night he dies. I already found a lot of scummy things and I haven't even finished rereading N1...