WW38: The Story of the Stories

[novice]

First days with no private posting in any mafia game involve lynching a random person and going from there. So do it.

We can at least focus the randomness towards people who have demonstrated a lack of interest in the general progress of the game with egregious lurking. Better than going full random and hitting someone who'd help substantially in later deduction

Noone except Lewwyn have offered any comment on Krill. It's as if he doesn't exist at all.

He's given a reason for not engaging D1 that I don't actually disagree with; you do get information from who the scum choose to kill N1, and with role madness there are other possible vectors to gain solid data overnight.

Mattimeo, you never answered Zak's question about these seemingly contradictory statements.

[Fenn]

I understand your position novice, but to me putting your vote on me 30 minutes before deadline without arguing for my guilt sounds less like pushing your top suspect and more like being unwilling to commit to either of the Gazglum/Molach wagons. Nobody took any apparent notice of your vote until the following night phase.

Meiz warrants some reconsideration for being the second on the Gazglum wagon and staying there until the end. I do not think his partner in treachery would so quickly send him off to the gallows.

I'm curious to see if zakalwe (or somebody else) shows up speaking in verse. It'd be helpful to be able to confirm if Jowy has been honest this whole time.

[pindicator]

Speaking of zak I'm still wanting for him to answer about Shadeun.

Novice, who else do you suspect besides Fenn?

[pindicator]

I agree with all of that up until the pindicator part.

And I agree with the argumentation of the wastrel up until he insults the wench AND the donkey!

Novice or his pet beast!

I'm really not liking how you keep dropping my name but not making a case Grignr. You know I'm on a full schedule too since you're playing with me in pbem64 and can see I'm not always timely in playing the turns. What, you sent me yesterday's turn at 6:30am hoping for a 2t day and I don't think I got to it until 10pm that night.

You also know that I'm PST time zone and that I work in the mornings right when deadline occurs but it doesn't stop you from insinuating I avoided the Gazglum push intentionally when the whole thing didn't even start until I was driving to work and in a meeting.

[Ichabod]

One thing that doesn't make sense in Novice as phony: why not vote Molach, when he voted Fenn, considering the Gaz push that was happening? Yeah, yeah, Molach could also be scum, but I really doubt it. In that light, Novice's switch doesn't make sense as a phony.

Mattimeo... There's probably something wrong when people agree with me so easily. People only agree with what you say when they want something from you (otherwise they just repeat what you say while saying they thought it themselves and they did it even before you said anything! The nerve!).

And, no kidding, Mattimeo play so far is basically meta + an analysis (pretty biased at that) on Meiz that he did while prompted by another player (i.e. not because of his own suspicion) + the consolidating vote on Molach, when the deadline was nearing and he could no longer justify the terrible Meiz vote. And the case on Molach is just based of the joke, really. Course, there's the "it's not just because of the joke" one liner, saying he dislikes the Adrien vote from Molach, but that's still bad, because it's pretty clear the big reason is the joke and that reason is bad. So, that's bad, really bad.

[zakalwe]

I'm curious to see if zakalwe (or somebody else) shows up speaking in verse. It'd be helpful to be able to confirm if Jowy has been honest this whole time.

Jowy speaks the truth
At least about the haikus
Unsurprisingly

[zakalwe]

Zak, I don't follow what you mean by saying Shadeun sounds scummy but you don't think that makes him scum. You mean it's something like my take on Moses, that it's too obvious to be scummy? I have to disagree if that's the case. Last game Rowain stuck his neck out late to save Fenn due to a rushed miscount; why don't you think this could be the same thing?

The jury is out
Not too scummy to be scum
But town points exist

No doubt about it
That vote could be lynchworthy
But maybe not yet

Mostly my point is
That Lewwyn was perceptive
To pinpoint his flaws

Scummy villagers
Can slip under the radar
If you know the truth

[zakalwe]

And just to be clear
The terms are quite lax
Verse will suffice
And rhyming is optional

I'm told to "inspire the team"
Maybe he has an arsenal of word spells
Or world spells
Or misspelled worlds
To confuse us into confusion

In hindsight
The barbarian gringo should have been his target
The difference
Would have been untold

[zakalwe]

A logical suspect
In my mind
So let's sit in a tree
And keep it simple
Stupid?

Mattimeo

[pindicator]

You suspect Jowy because of his ability? Am I reading that right ?