WW38: The Story of the Stories

[Krill]

I just hope Brick had some tylenol.

[zakalwe]

Zak can you eleborate on why you think Matt is suspicious.

It's been said before
I will collect the pieces
For convenience

Mattimeo was a bit inconsistent in his stance on Krill, and also pounded Molach for making a joke in this very serious situation. Seems out of character for him.

But if it's too late in the day for joke votes, why would you follow that up with a 'joke power'? It could be that he made his immunity claim to avoid a lynch, then saw that people were talking about lynching him anyway to test it, so he retroactively called it a joke.

I think this may be the original source of the contradiction argument. And the second part of this argument was also weak, which I noted at the time. In AdrienIer's favor, scum typically recycle arguments from townies, not from scumbuddies.

For comparison, Mattimeo put a slightly different spin on it when he voted for Molach.

Molach
Claiming invincibility to everything, rapidly backing down as soon as it looked like he might actually be called on it. Even if it was a joke, it's a pretty damn poor one, given how much in this game we have to take at people's word.
The only reasoning provided for his vote on Adrien ("opportunistic") describes his own vote a lot more accurately than it does anything Adrien has done.

"It's a pretty damn poor joke" strikes me as off, coming from Mattimeo. Feels like he's pushing way too hard, there. Also repeats the "opportunistic" argument that had been going around even though Molach had defended against that earlier.

A logical suspect
In my mind

I'm honestly not seeing how either you or zak is casting them as contradictory.

You first wanted to
Preserve the active players
He did not comply

He made a joke vote
And kept it there all day long
And then you approved

[Mattimeo]

Would the switch go through if target is jailed?

Generally depends on priority. As long as the GM has a list of the order actions take place in (which iirc BRick has been pretty good at), we're good.

For our side of things, I'd think gaoler should be before switching, due to its blocking element.
So, if everyone's telling the truth, likely sequence is:
Krill imprisoned Lewwyn
Adrien's switch was blocked
((kill on Lewwyn was blocked))

-- or could be kill Lewwyn made, but no. Really, no.

[Meiz]

That's what I'm thinking as well.

[AdrienIer]

The flavor of my role makes sense as high priority though, I manipulate everyone's mind so they think Lewwyn is Pindi and vice versa.

[Lewwyn]

Lewwyn I switched you and someone else last night, so you weren't actually jailed Pindicator was. And the wolves who targetted you ended up targetting jailed Pindi. So no confirmation

Is pindi the one you suspect most of being scum?

[Lewwyn]

And like I said, if my role got blocked I'll know at the end of the day. So we will have closure on the order of operations then.

[AdrienIer]

No I wanted to avoid getting in the way of a seer so I avoided the scummy people. So I chose the one who I felt was most neutral

[Rowain]

So claims so far:

Krill Jailed Lewwyn (jailing is not necessarily a town-skill )
Lewwyn did something he will only know at end of day if it worked.
Adrien switched Lewwyn with pindi
zakalwe targeted Jowy stopping his next nightaction
Jowy targeted zak with poetry (claim by zak not by jowy so far)

novice claims an ability he can't use before N 3


@Adrien How does your ability fit with your character? (how did BRick explain it?)

[AdrienIer]

My ability is very in-character with post "Robots and Empire" Daneel, where he gains mental powers.