WW40 - Game Thread

[Rowain]

If I had found a hero I'd have shut my mouth and try to remain in the shadow. Which is exactly what is happening.

Why would you as a torturer willingly let a proven villager getting mislynched?
If we have 3 gods we have 2 mislynches and then we are at LyLo. Why allow one mislynch which can be easily stopped?

Most importantly:
BRick claimed a big role and that he found a God. Why would a torturer still sit by and get him lynched when he can easily say: I'm torturer - BRick is innocent - lynch novice?

[AdrienIer]

If I had found a hero I'd have shut my mouth and try to remain in the shadow. Which is exactly what is happening.

Why would you as a torturer willingly let a proven villager getting mislynched?

In a normal situation everyone would be leaving BRick alone right now so as to avoid this kind of situation. I liked novice's post right after the torture, too bad he decided to change his mind.

Most importantly:
BRick claimed a big role and that he found a God. Why would a torturer still sit by and get him lynched when he can easily say: I'm torturer - BRick is innocent - lynch novice?

I guess this is true regardless of my vote so unless Matt (or Lewwyn I guess ?) has something to say I'll join you all on BRick

[zakalwe]

We're having guests and I cannot pay much attention to this at the moment. But I'm fine with lynching Brick.

[BRickAstley]

I will get to a computer for a proper quoting response but this is important: right after the torture post I made my gazing vote, and then got off to work on work. Serdoas pm came a few minutes after his past and right after I went offline, and I posted about it the first time I was back on.

Also that big posy gaz? 1i will give you, I've been too focused answering you and others and haven't been looking elsewhere. 2 is false I have said. 3 is horseshit since I have specifically answered you about that. 4 is because your reasons were based on a false understanding and A that annoys me B I could see that blossoming into you wanting to lunch me o oh look what's happening now. 567 like I said, I got the pm right after I got off RB and voted you. Also I am definitely Kassandra and without a given power role. Serdoa is under no obligation to make powers conform to how they 'make sense' thematically, though I can understand your point if everyone else's does.

[Gazglum]

Brick, did your message specifically say that Novice wanted to hurt us all?

[Rowain]

BRick

Why did the torturer not come forward to save you?

[Lewwyn]

Morning.

I mean this seems pretty simple to me. Brick is basically claiming novice is the torturer and the torturer is evil. But I think the torturer is a village role.

My wife's flight got delayed so I think I will be on for the deadline! Though now it looks pretty tame.

[BRickAstley]

Yeah that was the wording, wanted to hurt us all.

Romain I'm really not sure. I would think whoever the torturer is would come forward to clear me, but his not doing so is worrying.

Lewwyn... You know I hadn't considered the notion that that could mean novice is the torturer. I was just thinking village vs. Scum. It's clear he has something in that vein but I guess it could be torturer. If he's torturer then I do doubt that he is Scum too, that would be too mjw/tasunke game like.

[Lewwyn]

that one of the ones who wants to hurt us all is novice

I mean you said this. And so far we know there is a torturer in game so... for me that reads like novice is the one causing pain?

[BRickAstley]

"If Brick is innocent as you suggest, then you are arguing that mistakenly torturing an innocent townie has given us a succesful scan on a God. "

I am getting a sinking feeling that novice is really just a power role town instead of scum....