WW40 - Game Thread

[Jabbz]

That's cool. I'll even vote Jabbz so the vote doesn't go to anyone else. You guys just have to promise that when I pop as Perseus, you immediately vote to kill Zak and don't let him sway you into something else.

[Jabbz]

I'm going to add "even if there is no kill" in case he tries to use that as an argument. Once I die and pop town, everything I've said will hopefully gain more persuasiveness in your eyes.

[Marcus Aurelius]

eh ... Jabbz's self vote kinda flips it for me.

I'm having second thoughts on lynching Jabbz ...

Zakalwe

[AdrienIer]

Jabbz's self vote means he's either innocent or minion. In any case if Jabbz ends up town we lynch zak tomorrow. The only thing that could make us lose now is if Jabbz turned minion but Serdoa doesn't tell us at his death.

[zakalwe]

eh ... Jabbz's self vote kinda flips it for me.

I'm having second thoughts on lynching Jabbz ...

Zakalwe

I can't vote today, but there is nothing to stop Jabbz from changing his vote back at the last moment.

[Jabbz]

Sure there is, a desire to make sure that what I requested, that your death follow mine, is ensured. Were I to change it at the last minute, there are decent odds someone else would notice and change back, which would then ensure I was still lynched, but that I had evil intent in switching. At that point, you don't get lynched tomorrow. I win with town, my death is immaterial at this point, so there is nothing wrong with keeping your vote on me MA.

[AdrienIer]

There's something I don't understand : it would be perfectly natural for you to change to Zak now. That way if zak is indeed the last wolf we win tonight and don't have to go through a whole new day of potential doubts.

[novice]

If anything Jabbz self vote and volunteering for lynch is a scum tell, Marcus. This way he doesn't have to debate the case anymore and risk messing up.

[novice]

There's something I don't understand : it would be perfectly natural for you to change to Zak now. That way if zak is indeed the last wolf we win tonight and don't have to go through a whole new day of potential doubts.

Indeed. Sure, you can't switch last minute, but why not now? Zak is scum, after all - right?

[Jabbz]

Not at all novice. My concern here is that Zak dies. I do have a slight worry that there might be another scum, but to me that makes the numbers unfair against town. So would I prefer to kill Zak, absolutely. But as I see things right now, there appears to be very little doubt that you guys will kill him tomorrow, as you understand one of us is lying. I don't want to risk that, still die, and then have you guys kill anyone else tomorrow. I'm sorry if you see that as a scum tell, but hey, whatever. As far as debating and fearing messing up, I'll continue to answer any arguments up to the point of my death, to further ensure he gets lynched tomorrow.