WW #43 - The Asha'man

[novice]

Mafia Godfather is a pretty nice role to pass up

What do you mean by this, Psilly?

Re: mafia godfather: coming up as town if investigated by a cop is pretty nice, no?

I would agree. So discarding it is a town tell?

[Rowain]

@Psilly you are correct and I'm not an innocent child

@novice you are the one who would chose to display this role as discard exactly for that reason.


My town-leans so far: zakalwe and Jkaen: Both look like their town-selfs to me and I do believe that zak would rather play town instead of scum this game.

[Rowain]

I'd like some more presence from Prometheus. He hasn't offered anything beside an unorthodox view on backup doctor.

I concur

[AdrienIer]

Mafia Godfather is a pretty nice role to pass up

What do you mean by this, Psilly?

Re: mafia godfather: coming up as town if investigated by a cop is pretty nice, no?

I would agree. So discarding it is a town tell?

Not necessarily. You could have another mafia role (there are 7 of them I would consider putting above godfather)

[Psillycyber]

Mafia Godfather is a pretty nice role to pass up

What do you mean by this, Psilly?

Re: mafia godfather: coming up as town if investigated by a cop is pretty nice, no?

I would agree. So discarding it is a town tell?

Agreed. That's what I was implying in my first post. But then, Zak got me thinking that, if you really don't want to be mafia, then ordering your picks as town-mafia-town doesn't really make sense. Town-town-mafia would make more sense, which would cause a town role to show up as the public discard.

Now I see that novice has claimed vanilla townie as his third option, though, so now I can see why he would pick XXXX, mafia godfather, vanilla townie. VT is boring. I'm pretty sure I would pick anything over vanilla townie.

[Dp101]

Mafia Godfather is a pretty nice role to pass up

What do you mean by this, Psilly?

Re: mafia godfather: coming up as town if investigated by a cop is pretty nice, no?

I would agree. So discarding it is a town tell?

Not necessarily. You could have another mafia role (there are 7 of them I would consider putting above godfather)

Not accusing you of anything, just wondering, why would you put other mafia roles above godfather? For the cover?

[Rowain]

Why am I not voting for Psilly right now are simple the people voting for him:

Fenn whom I have no read currently and Adrien who ranks high in my internal scum-list.

Reason for Adrien is his passing on Hider and 1-shot-vig while at the same time he criticized Dp101 for discarding Mafia Lover

[AdrienIer]

What do you mean by this, Psilly?

Re: mafia godfather: coming up as town if investigated by a cop is pretty nice, no?

I would agree. So discarding it is a town tell?

Not necessarily. You could have another mafia role (there are 7 of them I would consider putting above godfather)

Not accusing you of anything, just wondering, why would you put other mafia roles above godfather? For the cover?

I said I would consider it, not that I would necessarily do it. But yes, I'd do it to do what Novice just possibly did and take cover behind the strong discard.
For the record the 7 roles are Mafia Roleblocker, Mafia Doctor, Mafia Strongman, Mafia One-shot Governor, Mafia Lover, Mafia One-shot Day Vigilante, Mafia Ninja (kills invisible to tracker/watcher)

[Rowain]

@novice Why do you think innocent child is a role fitting me?

[zakalwe]

In what way?

Verbose, but with a certain... je ne sais quoi.

He's trying hard to come across as sensible, I guess. He was more "unfiltered" last time.

In any case, Psilly.