WW #43 - The Asha'man

[novice]

So, how did I do in terms of providing content and things to think about that are not me? BTW, this is why I dislike day 1. I really enjoy building cases across lots of posts, and really don't know what to do without lots of things to look at. Hopefully I can contribute far more solidly to town now that I actually have something to work with.

Thanks for giving us your thoughts. You're not really building a convincing case on anyone, though. Frankly your suspicions seem tailored for survival. I'm becoming more towny to you as time goes on, when the general trend seems to be the reverse. Now Meiz is overtaking Lewwyn on your list without either player posting much between then and now. Rowain was a valid case yesterday but not after Prometheus flipped scum. If you could show Rowain to be scum that would exonerate your D2 voting somewhat, but you're just dismissing that suspicion. So you seem to be doing your best to just go wherever the wind is blowing.

One other point is that there is no reason you couldn't have done these kinds of reviews earlier. You're not really analyzing the flow of the game, to see who pushed what when, etc. In fairness this is hard to do even as town.

Ok. So I don't want to discourage you in the case that you're town, well played first game to you regardless of your alignment. I still think you're the best lynch today though. Or at least, the scummiest player.

[novice]

Novice, why didn't you go VT VT godfather?

My first preference was to play VT with a Godfather discard.
My second preference was to play Godfather with a VT discard.
My third preference was to play VT with a VT discard.

Makes sense?

[Gazglum]

Novice, why didn't you go VT VT godfather?

My first preference was to play VT with a Godfather discard.
My second preference was to play Godfather with a VT discard.
My third preference was to play VT with a VT discard.

Makes sense?

That does, crazily, make sense.

[Rowain]

Sure. If I am scum the congrats, if I am town then you have another confirmed town.

He might survive as scum too. After all there is a role called scum-doctor.


About novice: the reason why I find it the correct order: If Jabbz doesn't want him to play VT it doesn't matter if he has the Godfather as 2nd or 3rd place. And if he gets VT then it is far better to have the Godfather as shown discard instead of VT.

[Fenn]

You should absolutely shoot him. If he's town then he will be immune to it, its a no-lose situation. Is that how you unerstand it DP? Happy to do a bullet catch?

Beyond the possibility of a Mafia Doc, I'm worried about the possibility that scum has a Governor or Dayvig - if we mislynch today, then if I don't hit scum and Meiz either doesn't protect the right person or was scum all along, then the mafia will win on D4.

BTW, can Doctors protect themselves? Because if they can't, shooting Dp101 after a hypothetical scum lynch has absolutely no downsides.

[Dp101]

Novice, why didn't you go VT VT godfather?

My first preference was to play VT with a Godfather discard.
My second preference was to play Godfather with a VT discard.
My third preference was to play VT with a VT discard.

Makes sense?

Yup. I will have another look at the thread tonight to try and build some actual cases, it's just that it took me so long to get through the thread and type up isolated thoughts that by that point I had lost the will to turn them into cases.

[novice]

I will have to lock in my vote some hours before deadline tomorrow. I'm having a romantic birthday dinner with my wife, and somehow I think phone posts will be frowned upon.

[Gazglum]

Wives always come first. I hope we can sort it early tomorrow anyway. Goodnight team europe.

[Dp101]

So, how did I do in terms of providing content and things to think about that are not me? BTW, this is why I dislike day 1. I really enjoy building cases across lots of posts, and really don't know what to do without lots of things to look at. Hopefully I can contribute far more solidly to town now that I actually have something to work with.

Thanks for giving us your thoughts. You're not really building a convincing case on anyone, though. Frankly your suspicions seem tailored for survival. I'm becoming more towny to you as time goes on, when the general trend seems to be the reverse. Now Meiz is overtaking Lewwyn on your list without either player posting much between then and now. Rowain was a valid case yesterday but not after Prometheus flipped scum. If you could show Rowain to be scum that would exonerate your D2 voting somewhat, but you're just dismissing that suspicion. So you seem to be doing your best to just go wherever the wind is blowing.

One other point is that there is no reason you couldn't have done these kinds of reviews earlier. You're not really analyzing the flow of the game, to see who pushed what when, etc. In fairness this is hard to do even as town.

Ok. So I don't want to discourage you in the case that you're town, well played first game to you regardless of your alignment. I still think you're the best lynch today though. Or at least, the scummiest player.

Fair criticism. As to why I didn't do it earlier, I didn't think I could get that much info out of it because it was only day 2. Also I though I mentioned that I went back on my opinion regarding Rowain because it was mostly based off of other people's posts and how I felt at the time, and rereading allowed me to gain a better perspective on his play so far.

[Lewwyn]

I really am sorry I don't have more time.

I'm an enabler.

I really think Meiz is scum from the interactions yesterday and his fixation on novice. I also think novice is scummy, but I'm not sure if he and Meiz would be on a team.