[Lurkers] WW #43 - The Great Wheel

[Gazglum]

I got it!

'Taming our gaiety', and the dancing banana. 'See above'. You hid behind Lewwyn.

I am sure of this as I was that Meiz and Rowain were scum!

[Gazglum]

Who I also scanned last night, but obviously didn't get a result.

[sunrise089]

Not a big confidence booster. Given your clue I'm thinking the Narkissos reference and the 'taming our gaeity' phrase are clues, but I still can't connect those to a player.

Edit: cross

[Rowain]

Given that there aren't that many possibilities and Gazglum makes sense with zak's remark I agree on Lewwyn.

But I still don't see how. So in a game I would still stay on novice.

[Gazglum]

This is absolutely hilarious.

[Jabbz]

I figured dead men tell no tales, so dead men get no results. :P Just wanted to keep you on edge a while longer Gaz.

[Rowain]

Now that is interesting

Ok, Dp, I'll cut you a deal. I'm a SK. Fenn is a SK. Town has already lost. If you lynch me Fenn will kill you and win. Remember, SKs are immune to mafia kills.

If you lynch Fenn, I'll kill Lewwyn and share victory with you.

Only one SK is immune to Mafia but the other is only 2-shot-bulletproof so the third kill goes through and who knows how often anyone has been a target. Even if there is a SK duel in the end one is bulletproof (if not used up) the other not at all.

If there are SKs I hope they had threads and posted their thoughts

[Gazglum]

Well, Fenn just hit the deadline so I guess the day ends? That seems to be the player consensus.

[Gazglum]

GG Novice! Very well played.

So, my copping wasn't so useful. It kind of shows up the odd dangers of a power role like that. I scanned Novice because I thought he was scummy, then he came back clean. I considered that he might be a serial killer, but the odds of that were so low, that I felt it wasn't worth pursuing. I feel like it's always going to be more likely that someone you're not sure about could be scum than the 4% chance of a specific person being a serial killer, and so in that situation I feel like ignoring Novice was the best town play, even though it backfired in this instance. So in the end, I maybe hurt us more than helped by scanning him.

Anyway, obviously it helped a lot that Novice held his shot back, so we didn't even know a serial killer existed.

Scum win?

[zakalwe]

Well played, Novice.