WW 44: Battlestar Galactica

[AdrienIer]

Dp and Winston, could you refresh my memory about what timezones you're in? That way I can unfairly accuse you of not posting when you should have time, at a later date.

Dp is US west coast, so definitely asleep right now

[Gazglum]

Gentlemen please! We have all been out of the water so long, we are afraid to dip our toes back in? I guess the first step is always the hardest, especially if you're trying to feign nonchalance. Which actually gives me an idea - maybe next time we play I will avoid looking at my role PM until half-way through the first day, then I can get the early posts out of the way with the assumption of my own innocence. Or maybe...I'm doing that now....

Winston, I hope you're not feeling too poorly, your response to Jabbz feels a little stiff. Where's the good natured chat and joke vote?

There are many new shades of red offered on my forum posts. Is there an official colour we need to use for the vote tracker?

[Dp101]

We're back! It's great to see you guys again.

Now, Battlestar Galactica is a fine show, and we wouldn't want to spoil anything for anybody who hasn't seen it. So let's not cast any aspersions as to who may or may not be a Cylon based on what we might remember, right Dp101? 

Hi everyone! Gazglum, I appreciate your fine memory but I must also cling to tradition, in my case the time-honed strategy of "everyone who votes me is mafia".

[Dp101]

Gentlemen please! We have all been out of the water so long, we are afraid to dip our toes back in? I guess the first step is always the hardest, especially if you're trying to feign nonchalance. Which actually gives me an idea - maybe next time we play I will avoid looking at my role PM until half-way through the first day, then I can get the early posts out of the way with the assumption of my own innocence. Or maybe...I'm doing that now....

Winston, I hope you're not feeling too poorly, your response to Jabbz feels a little stiff. Where's the good natured chat and joke vote?

There are many new shades of red offered on my forum posts. Is there an official colour we need to use for the vote tracker?

And in the same minute he changes his vote! I think the vote tracker is dead with the forum upgrade, so I don't think the red we pick matters. Overall though, sorry, but this post feels vaguely scummy, the first paragraph is teasing the town as to the possibility of being mafia (which strikes me as something mafia is more likely to enjoy doing than town) and the winston vote feels a little weak, although it does get town points for having the first set of reasons on display in the thread so far. Only a slight read from this overall.

[Gazglum]

Good man! Points and reasons! Perhaps the others can chime in too.

[novice]

It's great to see all of you again. Wife time now, so see you all later.

PS Why is no one voting for me?
PPS Gaz hides his disappointment with another town draw well.

[AdrienIer]

Gazglum there may be little chatter but it's also because there aren't many of us here. This isn't a 11 player game where D1 starts getting crazy super fast.

I see that you suggest lynching Winston early, which worked perfectly for scum in the last game he played. And you want us to chime in on your attack on him ? Well I'll chime in : I don't like it. He plays on other forums and has a different style. Nothing scummy about that. If suddenly Lewwyn (for example) was to act all non RB-like I'd be more surprised and suspicious.

[Jabbz]

Yeah, I played one of his games with him a few weeks back. It was a shit show, host called it because two people were horribly at each others throats. Hopefully he won't bring that here. I think novice is trying to make sure he has someone voting against him later so he can point to it for a fake clear. Scummy as heck IMO.

[Dp101]

Could you explain that novice vote in a bit more detail? I don't understand how someone voting against them could be used to clear them.

[AdrienIer]

Same question