WW 44: Battlestar Galactica

[Gazglum]

Individually I can take them as mistakes, a fervent townie leaping at all possible scum tells. Taken as a whole whoever, the repetitive nature of his posts making the same kind of mistake and being corrected by others, smells different. I'm not sure he is scum, but he seems scummier than anyone else on my list.

I'm not ruling this out, but I'd need more before i voted him. And DP is voting Adrien, my preferred suspect, so at the moment I am hoping that he is locked in on a wolf.

[Lewwyn]

I also agree on a possible Wolf Blitz. I think the best way to win a 2 vs 5 game for wolves is to play as risky as they need to on Day 1 to get their mislynch, because 2v3 is then very hard for town to stop. So Adrien + Lewwyn seems plausible to me too.

Speaking of a Wolf Blitz...

Gazglum and Winston, you guys seem pretty damn chummy.

It rhymes with scummy.

I was actually responding to Adrien here, this was a bipartisan agree-fest on wolf-tactics.

Do you think Winston is scummy? I agree almost exactly with his town>scum suspicion list, so it is hard not to feel a bit chummy towards.

Read up, I mistook one of his comments for the inverse of what he meant. So no.

[AdrienIer]

Incredible how my D1 is always twice as hard when I'm town

[Gazglum]

No new votes since I last came here ? Winston is still voting for a third party ? How is that useful ?

I'm also a bit unhappy that Winston went from 'I think Lewwyn + Adrien is a very plausible scum team' to 'oh, its all shades of town'. Encouraging my instincts and then disengaging somewhat.

But I do still find you the scummiest, Adrien. I agree with Novice that 'not considering DP's tone when prosecuting him' is a red flag. It feels to me like you are struggling more than most to find a suspect you can commit to, which would make sense if you don't have any.

[Lewwyn]

I agree with Novice that 'not considering DP's tone when prosecuting him' is a red flag.

Which post is this?

[Qgqqqqq]

So:

The player with most lynch votes at the end of the day is lynched and eliminated from the game. Tiebreaks: There is a tiebreaking mechanism that exists, and makes sense to the GM.

What is that tiebreak mechanism?

You don't get to know.

[AdrienIer]

Did you even consider the timing of my post Gaz ? I wake up, you (my primary target) hasn't posted so I want to find someone else. You can call that "struggling to find a suspect" if you want

[Gazglum]

Something that I'm trying to keep in mind is that with 7 players the dynamics are different. Our cop is probably our best asset so the main priority is not to get him killed, but maybe the scum team will want to try something new (with a possible lylo on D2)

Adrien, what did you mean by this? What was the point of bringing it up, how do you want us to play differently? This post felt like it might be you hinting towards a claim, but then you suggested that your are vanilla town, so then this feels more like just trying to change the subject.

[Gazglum]

I agree with Novice that 'not considering DP's tone when prosecuting him' is a red flag.

Which post is this?

Novice to Jabbz, #127

[Dp101]

I'm feeling moderately uneasy with regards to my vote currently, but don't want to change due to self-pres. If anyone is wondering, it is AdrienIer's comment about how their D1 is always twice as hard as town that is pinging me as probably town.