WW 45: I'm an Illegal Alien

[Lewwyn]

Finally, some posts. I don't love Lew's case against me and Jabbz, but I hate the vote on Jabbz more, as others have said, why put the vote on the guy who there is less of a case against? I'm not sure if the nostalgia talk is alignment indicative, but either way, it feels wrong to vote people for idle conversation. Probably not going to change my vote for now.

So you don't like me voting for Jabbz (hate is a strong word...), but you're voting for Jabbz, and you're not going to change your vote for now?

Can't let everyone think you're jumping off your scumbuddy too quickly now, eh? Gotta keep up appearances!

[Dp101]

Finally, some posts. I don't love Lew's case against me and Jabbz, but I hate the vote on Jabbz more, as others have said, why put the vote on the guy who there is less of a case against? I'm not sure if the nostalgia talk is alignment indicative, but either way, it feels wrong to vote people for idle conversation. Probably not going to change my vote for now.

So you don't like me voting for Jabbz (hate is a strong word...), but you're voting for Jabbz, and you're not going to change your vote for now?

Can't let everyone think you're jumping off your scumbuddy too quickly now, eh? Gotta keep up appearances!

I'm not changing my vote because I don't have any strong options right now, not because they are genuinely scummy. Or at least that was the case, your interpretation of this is reaching at best. Lewwyn

[Jabbz]

Second, saying 'this isn't making you look good' is suggesting that Rowain's responses to you are scummy. Or that making the argument he is making is not in line with Rowain's town game. I think that even if you disagree with Rowain, it is a stretch to think that his post is not town-like. Town Rowain is often who I disagree with most!

Yup, I did find it scummy, you hit the nail right on the head.

[Jabbz]

What don't you like about DP?

Mostly just as I read through DP and Jabbz interactions felt premeditated in a scummy kind of way.

Oh right, I forgot, Jabbz since I'm still salty from last time.

Really you forgot?
Then:

Odd setup is odd.

So my understanding would be that scum get to put 3 townies up for lynch on day 2, and we as town have to decide which one we can most afford to lose? Is there any possibility of killing a scum on day 2? There almost has to be at least 1 scum in the trio put forth, otherwise with our limited number it outs the scum as one of the 3 people not in that pile.  My head hurts.

Clinging to tradition. Dp101.

Voting for DP here. SO now they have voted for each other.

Also want to point out that the "my head hurts" feels artificial to me.

Jabbz then quickly moves his vote off to Rowain counter attacking the attack.

If you look back to our last game, you will see that I also started there with humor, I'm kind of going for a trend. It'll be like, oh hey, there's Jabbz day one, where is his terrible joke? Ya know what I mean?

The vote on him is a direct quote from the last game which he used early on, and then got massive shit for. Given I used him as a patsy last game, I felt it was appropriate, and more importantly, funny.

Then:

Odd setup is odd.

So my understanding would be that scum get to put 3 townies up for lynch on day 2, and we as town have to decide which one we can most afford to lose? Is there any possibility of killing a scum on day 2? There almost has to be at least 1 scum in the trio put forth, otherwise with our limited number it outs the scum as one of the 3 people not in that pile.  My head hurts.

Clinging to tradition. Dp101.

I would expect that they put at least one in the three, since it is an auto-lose otherwise. Well, actually, only if is it expected that they put none in is it a recipe for loss, otherwise the people not nominated are the ones under suspicion. Like you, my head hurts.

Wait Dp's head hurts too? CAHOOTS!

But seriously, DP is still voting for Jabbz at this point. Also DP feels formal, uses too many commas.

Suffice to say I may be projecting slightly because as scum in small games like this I often vote for my scumbuddy first. Still, something's stinky.

It's possible he is scum, too early to say IMO, but I know I'm not. If yall want to vote for me though that's ok. I'll keep up my analysis throughout the day, and when I pop town A: you'll have a long list of shit to analyze, and B: I'll be able to start my own game with less obligations :P

[Jabbz]

I also want to throw in here (not caught up, just on post 41) I will have no hard feelings if I'm mislynched. After my performance last game, and my intent to engage people in the exact same calm and bad joking way, I've earned it.

[Jabbz]

Nice thing about small games, easy to catch up.

So if I understand this right, I'm scummy because:

A: I have a problem with what I view as rowain's overreaction to me talking meta, which everyone was doing.
B: I somehow have some semblance of a mind meld (with both Dp and Llewyn)
C: I voted for Dp101 first (in an obvious joke post referring back to last game) and Llewyn often votes his scumbuddy first in small games.
D: Because you guys are still miffed about last game :P

Does that pretty much cover it?

I still find Rowain's post to be questionable. I think he recognizes I'm an easy place to shift suspicion based on last game, and is looking to start an easy lynch. The fact that he doesn't vote for me is quite frankly irrelevant. If he doesn't need the vote to start the train, so much the better, as he can keep his hands clean of the D1 lynch, like Llewyn and I did last game. That shit's a straight up gift lol.  I think Rowain's attacks, whether scum or town, are simply going after low hanging fruit, and don't seem all that interested in finding scum. Until something better comes along, that moderate scum point I gave him keeps my vote on him.

Off to run some errands with the wife shortly. Will catch up later.

[Lewwyn]

you're trying extra hard to sell the calm tone stuff, but when I disagree with what you're saying does that even matter?

[Jabbz]

I'm not sure I follow how those two items work together.

Also, for the record, I am calm, and I'm not selling it This is now game three like this, I'm pretty sure it qualifies as a trend at this point, especially because I was both town and scum in the previous games where I interacted this way.

[Jabbz]

Oh well, I'm off to bed. I believe we have one day left, so I guess we will see what happens. Night folks.

[Lewwyn]

I'm not sure I follow how those two items work together.

Also, for the record, I am calm, and I'm not selling it This is now game three like this, I'm pretty sure it qualifies as a trend at this point, especially because I was both town and scum in the previous games where I interacted this way.

I'm saying that the tone or how calm you are or whether you'd act that way no matter scum or villager doesn't matter. I disagree with your logic. That makes me think there are thinks you are intentionally misunderstanding. Trend continues with this post.